Safariland Model 5199 Open Top Concealment Clip w/Detent Holster Review

Taking the Safariland Model 5199 Open Top Concealment Clip w/Detent Holster for a Spin

For years, I’ve been navigating the often-murky waters of concealment holsters, constantly seeking that elusive blend of security, accessibility, and comfort for my everyday carry needs. My search for a reliable holster for my Glock 17 and Glock 22, specifically for plainclothes work and range use, led me to the Safariland Model 5199 Open Top Concealment Clip w/Detent Holster. This particular model caught my eye due to its promise of a secure retention system and the ease of a clip-on design, a combination I find invaluable in dynamic environments. I was tired of holsters that compromised either retention or draw speed, and the reputation of Safariland as a serious player in the duty and concealment markets certainly piqued my interest.

My previous experiences with similar concealment holsters have been a mixed bag. Some offered excellent retention but were cumbersome to draw from, feeling like a wrestling match every time I needed to access my firearm. Others were so minimalist that I worried about my weapon retaining its place during vigorous movement. I’d even experimented with a few Kydex options from smaller manufacturers, but none quite hit the mark for consistent retention and comfort over extended wear. The allure of the Safariland 5199 was its stated balance: a compact, lightweight design with a trigger guard detent for retention, coupled with a straightforward belt clip. My initial impression upon receiving this holster was one of solid, no-nonsense construction. The STX Tactical finish felt robust and non-reflective, and the overall profile was blessedly slim.

First Use Experience

My first foray with the Safariland Model 5199 Open Top Concealment Clip w/Detent Holster was at my local indoor range, during a standard proficiency drill session. The holster attached effortlessly to my 1.75-inch tactical belt. The sturdy belt clip felt secure, with no hint of slippage as I moved through my drills. Drawing the Glock 17 was surprisingly smooth, with the trigger guard detent providing a palpable click as it cleared the holster, assuring me of its retention.

Conditions were standard for an indoor range – controlled temperature and consistent lighting. The real test came during a longer training session where I simulated various movements, including crouching, reaching, and even a controlled tumble. The holster maintained its position and kept the firearm securely in place throughout.

Ease of use was a significant win from the outset. There was no complex adjustment period or fiddly parts to learn. The low-cut sides for ease of draw were immediately apparent, allowing for a full firing grip without interference. My only minor surprise was the snugness of the initial fit; it took a few draws to break in the holster perfectly to my specific firearm.

Extended Use & Reliability

After several weeks of consistent wear, both on and off the range, the Safariland Model 5199 Open Top Concealment Clip w/Detent Holster has proven its mettle. I’ve carried it during my daily commute, errands, and several extended training days, and it continues to perform admirably. The holster has seen exposure to light dust and the occasional sweat drip without any noticeable degradation in performance or appearance.

Durability has been excellent so far. The STX Tactical finish shows only minor, almost imperceptible scuffs where it contacts my belt. There are no cracks, no warping, and the trigger guard detent retains its positive engagement with the firearm. The clip mechanism remains as strong as day one, showing no signs of fatigue or loosening.

Maintenance is refreshingly simple. A quick wipe-down with a damp cloth is usually all it needs. For a deeper clean, I’ve used a soft brush and mild soap, which restores its appearance effectively. I haven’t encountered any specific issues that require special attention, which is a testament to its robust design. Compared to some cheaper, less robust holsters I’ve used in the past, this Safariland model feels like a significant upgrade in terms of longevity and consistent performance. It’s a solid performer that doesn’t demand constant attention.

Breaking Down the Features of Safariland Model 5199 Open Top Concealment Clip w/Detent Holster

Specifications

The Safariland Model 5199 Open Top Concealment Clip w/Detent Holster is built with practicality and concealed carry in mind. Its primary construction material is a durable, proprietary polymer, finished in STX Tactical black, which offers a non-reflective surface ideal for concealment. This material is known for its resilience to impact and environmental factors.

The holster features a trigger guard detent, a crucial element that engages the trigger guard of the firearm, providing a passive retention point. This detent, combined with the friction fit of the holster, ensures the firearm stays put under normal circumstances. The design also incorporates low-cut sides, which are specifically engineered to facilitate a more accessible and quicker draw by allowing a full firing grip on the pistol before it leaves the holster.

One of the most user-friendly specifications is its sturdy belt clip. This clip is designed to accommodate belt widths ranging from 1.5 inches (38 mm) up to 2.25 inches (58 mm), making it versatile for various belt types, from standard dress belts to wider tactical belts. The clip’s robust construction ensures it stays attached to the belt even during dynamic movement. This model is IDPA approved, which speaks to its suitability for competitive shooting where specific holster requirements are mandated. The overall design prioritizes a compact and lightweight profile, essential for comfortable all-day concealed carry.

Performance & Functionality

The core job of any holster is to securely retain a firearm while allowing for a swift and efficient draw, and the Safariland Model 5199 Open Top Concealment Clip w/Detent Holster performs admirably in this regard. The trigger guard detent is the star feature here; it provides a noticeable and reassuring click as the firearm seats, and critically, as it is drawn. This detent offers a level of security that surpasses many simple friction-fit holsters, preventing unwanted dislodging without requiring a thumb break or active retention mechanism.

The low-cut sides truly make a difference, allowing for a complete grip on the pistol before you even begin to draw. This capability is paramount for faster and more effective deployment under stress. The open-top design means no flapping covers or retention straps to manipulate, further streamlining the draw stroke.

Considering its price point of $45.99, the performance is exceptional. It meets and often exceeds the expectations set by holsters costing significantly more. The STX Tactical material has proven durable, resisting scuffs and retaining its shape. The only minor area for potential improvement, and this is being very critical, is that for some extremely precise shooting disciplines, the inherent flex of a polymer holster might be less desirable than a rigid Kydex or leather alternative. However, for general concealment and practical shooting, its functionality is top-tier.

Design & Ergonomics

The Safariland Model 5199 Open Top Concealment Clip w/Detent Holster embodies a practical, functional design philosophy. The use of STX Tactical material gives it a robust yet lightweight feel. Its matte black finish is understated, which is perfect for concealment, as it doesn’t attract undue attention.

Ergonomically, the holster is well-thought-out for its intended purpose. The low-cut sides are a standout feature, promoting a natural and unhindered acquisition of the firing grip. This design choice significantly contributes to comfortable all-day wear, as it doesn’t dig into the hip or restrict movement.

The sturdy belt clip is a marvel of simple engineering. It opens wide enough to easily attach to or remove from a belt, but once in place, it grips firmly. The internal design of the clip, combined with the holster’s profile, keeps the firearm held close to the body, minimizing printing and maximizing concealment. There’s a minimal learning curve; it’s an intuitive design that works straight out of the box.

Durability & Maintenance

From my experience, the Safariland Model 5199 Open Top Concealment Clip w/Detent Holster is built to last. The STX Tactical material is renowned for its resilience, and after weeks of consistent use, I see no signs of premature wear. The polymer has held its form perfectly, and the trigger guard detent maintains its positive engagement.

Maintenance is straightforward and requires minimal effort. A simple cleaning with mild soap and water, followed by an air dry, is usually sufficient. For more stubborn dirt or grime, a soft-bristled brush can be used gently. There are no complex mechanisms or delicate parts that are prone to failure or require specialized tools for upkeep.

The primary potential point of wear over extended periods would be the sturdy belt clip, but given its robust construction, I anticipate it will hold up well under normal daily use. It’s designed for repeated attachment and detachment, and I haven’t experienced any loosening or weakening of the spring tension in the clip. This holster is a low-maintenance piece of gear, which is exactly what you want for a daily carry item.

Accessories and Customization Options

The Safariland Model 5199 Open Top Concealment Clip w/Detent Holster comes as a standalone unit, primarily focused on its core function. It doesn’t include significant accessories, but its design is inherently compatible with a range of belt types and widths, up to 2.25 inches (58 mm). The IDPA approval suggests its suitability for certain competitive contexts, where other accessories might be regulated.

Customization, in the traditional sense, is limited with this particular model, as it’s designed for a specific firearm fit (Glock 17/22 in this case) and a fixed belt clip attachment. However, its simplicity is also its strength. The absence of adjustable tension screws or elaborate retention mechanisms means there’s less to go wrong and less to tinker with. If you were looking for more adjustable cant or ride height, you might need to consider other Safariland models or aftermarket solutions that can adapt to different mounting platforms. For its intended purpose as a straightforward concealed carry holster with a clip, it stands on its own as a highly functional piece of equipment.

Pros and Cons of Safariland Model 5199 Open Top Concealment Clip w/Detent Holster

Who Should Buy Safariland Model 5199 Open Top Concealment Clip w/Detent Holster?

This holster is an excellent choice for individuals who prioritize a balance of concealment, security, and rapid access for their Glock 17 or Glock 22. It’s ideal for everyday concealed carry, plainclothes law enforcement, or anyone who appreciates a no-nonsense, reliable holster. Those who frequently change belts or prefer a clip-on system for ease of attachment and detachment will find the sturdy belt clip particularly beneficial.

However, individuals who require a highly adjustable holster with a wide range of cant and ride-height options might want to explore other Safariland models or different holster types. Shooters who absolutely require active retention devices beyond a passive detent may also need to look elsewhere. For anyone seeking a straightforward, dependable concealment holster that offers a secure fit and a smooth draw, this model is a strong contender.

If you plan on carrying this holster regularly, investing in a sturdy, 1.5 to 2.25-inch belt designed for concealed carry will maximize its effectiveness and comfort. A good belt will ensure the belt clip has a solid platform to grip, preventing sag and ensuring consistent firearm retention.

Conclusion on Safariland Model 5199 Open Top Concealment Clip w/Detent Holster

The Safariland Model 5199 Open Top Concealment Clip w/Detent Holster stands out as a pragmatic and highly effective solution for concealed carry. Its blend of a secure trigger guard detent, a fast-draw-optimized low-cut design, and a versatile sturdy belt clip creates a package that is both reliable and comfortable for daily wear. The STX Tactical finish and robust construction speak to Safariland’s commitment to producing durable gear.

At a price of $45.99, the value proposition is outstanding. You receive a holster that performs like a much more expensive piece of equipment, offering a secure fit and a smooth draw that instills confidence. While it may lack the extensive adjustability of some higher-end modular holsters, its focused design for concealment and accessibility is precisely what many users need.

I would confidently recommend the Safariland Model 5199 Open Top Concealment Clip w/Detent Holster to anyone looking for a no-fuss, high-performance concealment holster for their Glock 17 or Glock 22. It’s a tool that gets the job done efficiently and reliably, day in and day out.