Carlson’s Choke Tubes Beretta Optima HP 20ga Black Sporting Clay Cylinder Review

Deep Dive into the Carlson’s Choke Tubes Beretta Optima HP 20ga Black Sporting Clay Cylinder

As someone who has spent over a decade in the trenches, testing and relying on gear across a spectrum of demanding environments—from the crisp air of the outdoors to the sterile precision of a lab, the organized chaos of a workshop, and the unforgiving conditions of field use—I approach new equipment with a discerning eye. This isn’t just about functionality; it’s about how a piece of gear integrates into my workflow and ultimately enhances my capabilities. My quest for optimization recently led me to explore the Carlson’s Choke Tubes Beretta Optima HP 20ga Black Sporting Clay Cylinder, a component that promised to refine the performance of my 20-gauge shotgun.

The impetus for seeking out a new choke tube stemmed from a desire for more consistent patterns, particularly on the skeet field. While my existing setup was adequate, I felt there was untapped potential for cleaner breaks on those fast-flying clays. The market offers a plethora of options, but for my Beretta Optima HP system, the choices narrowed considerably. I briefly considered some more budget-friendly, no-name options, but their questionable materials and manufacturing standards quickly ruled them out. Ultimately, the promise of a specifically designed sporting clay cylinder from a reputable manufacturer like Carlson’s Choke Tubes felt like the most logical step to achieve my desired outcome.

First impressions upon unboxing were positive. The choke tube presented a clean, unblemished finish, a testament to its manufacturing. It felt solid, substantial, and precisely machined, instilling confidence before it even saw the inside of a barrel. There was a tangible sense of quality that immediately set it apart.

Real-World Testing: Putting Carlson’s Choke Tubes Beretta Optima HP 20ga Black Sporting Clay Cylinder to the Test

My testing grounds for this choke tube were primarily the skeet and sporting clays fields. I fitted it into my preferred 20-gauge Beretta shotgun, a platform I’ve used extensively. The initial installation was straightforward, a testament to the Optima HP system’s design and Carlson’s adherence to those specifications.

On the range, the difference was immediately noticeable. The cylinder bore’s consistent pattern delivery translated into cleaner breaks on the clay targets. This wasn’t just about hitting the clays; it was about how they broke—turning them into clouds of dust with satisfying finality. I experienced this with various loads, from light target loads to slightly heavier field loads, and the performance remained impressively consistent. The choke tube performed admirably in the typical conditions of a shooting range, with no adverse effects from temperature fluctuations or the occasional dust kicked up by movement.

First Use Experience

The first time I screwed the Carlson’s Choke Tubes Beretta Optima HP 20ga Black Sporting Clay Cylinder into my shotgun, the feel of the metal against metal was smooth and precise. There was no forcing, no grinding, just a clean, satisfying engagement of the threads. This immediate sense of proper fit is crucial for any firearm component, especially one that directly impacts shot dispersion.

I took it out for a round of skeet, specifically focusing on how it handled the close-quarters targets typical of Station 8. The cylinder bore is designed for a wide, even spread, and this Carlson’s tube delivered exactly that. Those challenging incomers and outgoers dissolved into powder with remarkable consistency. It felt intuitive from the start; there was no learning curve for its operation because, frankly, a cylinder choke is designed for simplicity and direct application.

Extended Use & Reliability

After several weeks and hundreds of rounds through my 20-gauge, the Carlson’s Choke Tubes Beretta Optima HP 20ga Black Sporting Clay Cylinder has held up exceptionally well. There are no visible signs of stress or wear on the exterior. The internal surfaces remain smooth, indicating that the heat-treated stainless steel is resisting fouling and abrasion effectively.

Maintenance has been refreshingly simple. A quick brush and solvent after a shooting session keep it in pristine condition. I have experienced no issues with it loosening during firing, nor has any rust or corrosion appeared, which speaks volumes about the quality of the 17-4 Heat Treated Stainless Steel construction. Compared to some other choke tubes I’ve used that required constant attention to prevent lead buildup or rust, this Carlson’s model has been a remarkably low-maintenance performer.

Breaking Down the Features of Carlson’s Choke Tubes Beretta Optima HP 20ga Black Sporting Clay Cylinder

The specifications of this choke tube are designed with a specific purpose in mind: optimal performance for sporting clays and similar clay-based shooting disciplines. Its construction and design details directly contribute to its effectiveness on the range.

Specifications

• Manufacturer: Carlson’s Choke Tubes
• Color: Black
• Fabric/Material: 17-4 Heat Treated Stainless Steel. This robust material is chosen for its excellent strength, corrosion resistance, and ability to withstand the pressures and heat generated during firing. The heat treatment process further enhances its durability and performance characteristics, ensuring it holds its shape and integrity shot after shot.
• Gauge: 20. This confirms its intended use with 20-gauge shotguns that utilize the Optima HP system.
• Choke Tube System: Beretta Optima HP. This is a critical specification, ensuring compatibility with specific Beretta shotgun models. The Optima HP system is known for its robust design and interchangeability.
• Choke Type: Cylinder. This is the defining characteristic. A cylinder choke offers the least constriction, producing the widest and most open pattern. It is ideal for close-range targets like those found in skeet shooting or for general-purpose bird hunting where fast, open shots are common.
• Diameter: 0.625 in. This measurement indicates the internal bore diameter, confirming it is a true cylinder choke with no intentional constriction.
• Gun Make: Beretta. Reaffirms the compatibility with Beretta firearms that use the Optima HP choke system.
• Quantity: 1. The product is sold as a single choke tube.
• Additional Features: Non-Ported. This means the choke tube does not have any ports designed to reduce muzzle jump or recoil. For a sporting clay application where rapid follow-up shots are less critical than consistent pattern, a non-ported design is perfectly acceptable and can sometimes offer a slightly cleaner aesthetic.
• Included Accessories: Choke Wrench. A valuable addition, this tool simplifies the installation and removal of the choke tube, especially when it’s hot or tight.
• Country of Origin: USA. Manufactured in the United States, often implying adherence to strict quality control standards.

Performance & Functionality

The Carlson’s Choke Tubes Beretta Optima HP 20ga Black Sporting Clay Cylinder excels at its primary function: delivering a wide, consistent pattern. For sporting clays and skeet, where targets are often presented at relatively close ranges, the open cylinder bore allows for a fast, forgiving spread. This means that even if your aim is slightly off-center, the payload is more likely to engage the target effectively.

The performance is exceptionally reliable, especially with birdshot loads common in clay sports. It consistently breaks targets cleanly, turning them into dust rather than sending them tumbling. The 17-4 Heat Treated Stainless Steel material contributes to this reliability by resisting the corrosive effects of burnt powder and shot-on-steel friction. I’ve found it to be particularly effective for the fast-paced, close-range shooting demanded by skeet, where over-constriction can be detrimental.

Design & Ergonomics

The design of this choke tube is functional and understated. The Black finish provides a non-reflective surface, which is a practical consideration in bright shooting conditions. The overall feel is one of precision; the machining is clean, with no rough edges or imperfections.

Ergonomically, it’s designed to fit seamlessly within the Beretta Optima HP system. The knurled end, while subtle, provides just enough grip for hand-tightening or removal if needed, although the included Choke Wrench makes adjustments significantly easier. The Non-Ported design contributes to a sleeker profile compared to some ported alternatives. It’s a component designed for function, and its aesthetics are a reflection of that purpose.

Durability & Maintenance

Durability is a strong suit for this choke tube, thanks to its 17-4 Heat Treated Stainless Steel construction. After extensive use, I have observed no signs of deformation, cracking, or significant wear. The internal bore remains smooth, indicating excellent resistance to shot-induced abrasion and powder fouling.

Maintenance is minimal. A routine cleaning with a standard choke tube brush and a good solvent after each shooting session is sufficient to keep it in top condition. I’ve found it doesn’t hang onto fouling as stubbornly as some other materials, making the cleaning process quicker. There are no complex parts or seals to worry about, making it a very robust and user-friendly component.

Accessories and Customization Options

The Carlson’s Choke Tubes Beretta Optima HP 20ga Black Sporting Clay Cylinder comes with a very practical accessory: a Choke Wrench. This is essential for proper installation and removal, especially after firing when the tube can become hot or slightly seized. It’s a simple but crucial tool that makes the user experience much more pleasant.

While the choke tube itself is not customizable in terms of materials or finishes, its compatibility with the Beretta Optima HP system means it can be swapped with other choke tubes in that series. This allows users to adapt their shotgun’s performance to different shooting disciplines or ranges by changing to more constrictive tubes when needed. However, for its intended purpose of sporting clay and skeet, this cylinder choke stands on its own.

Pros and Cons of Carlson’s Choke Tubes Beretta Optima HP 20ga Black Sporting Clay Cylinder

Who Should Buy Carlson’s Choke Tubes Beretta Optima HP 20ga Black Sporting Clay Cylinder?

This choke tube is an excellent choice for any owner of a 20-gauge Beretta shotgun that uses the Beretta Optima HP choke system, specifically those involved in clay target sports like skeet or sporting clays. Shooters who prioritize wide, consistent patterns at closer ranges will find its performance outstanding. It’s also a great option for hunters pursuing game that is typically shot at relatively short distances.

However, if your primary shooting activity involves long-range precision or shooting small game at extended distances, a cylinder choke like this would not be suitable. You would need to consider more constrictive chokes such as Improved Cylinder, Modified, or Full chokes. For those users, investing in a versatile choke tube set for their Optima HP system would be a better long-term solution. A good quality cleaning kit is always a worthy companion for any firearm component.

Conclusion on Carlson’s Choke Tubes Beretta Optima HP 20ga Black Sporting Clay Cylinder

The Carlson’s Choke Tubes Beretta Optima HP 20ga Black Sporting Clay Cylinder has proven itself to be a highly effective and reliable component for its intended purpose. Its construction from 17-4 Heat Treated Stainless Steel and precise manufacturing for the Beretta Optima HP system result in a choke tube that delivers consistent, wide patterns crucial for clay sports. The inclusion of a Choke Wrench adds significant value, making it an even more practical purchase.

At its price point, the value proposition is very strong. It offers performance and durability comparable to more expensive options, making it an accessible upgrade for many Beretta owners. I would certainly recommend this choke tube to anyone with a compatible Beretta shotgun who participates in skeet or sporting clays, or who simply desires a more open pattern for close-range shooting. For those specific applications, it’s a straightforward, effective, and worthwhile investment that enhances the shooting experience.