DeSantis New York Undercover Rig Shoulder Leather Holster Review

Ready to Know the Truth About the DeSantis New York Undercover Rig Shoulder Leather Holster?

For over a decade, I’ve relied on equipment that can withstand the rigors of diverse environments, from dusty workshops and sterile labs to rugged outdoor expeditions. When the need arose for a robust and reliable shoulder holster, the DeSantis New York Undercover Rig Shoulder Leather Holster repeatedly came up in discussions. This particular model promised a blend of classic design and modern functionality, crafted from what DeSantis touts as top-grain cowhide. My own experience with this holster, particularly following a lengthy wait, offered a nuanced perspective on its capabilities and limitations.

The impetus for this purchase stemmed from a desire for a more comfortable and secure carry solution for a specific firearm that my existing collection of holsters didn’t quite accommodate optimally. I had been using a less-than-ideal setup that compromised both accessibility and comfort, and the promise of a well-established design like the New York Undercover seemed like a sensible upgrade. Initial impressions, even before extended use, suggested a product built with a certain heritage in mind, though I couldn’t help but compare it mentally to the precision of offerings from brands like Safariland, which I’ve also extensively utilized. My first reaction was one of cautious optimism, hoping the prolonged wait would indeed translate to a worthwhile investment.

Real-World Testing: Putting the DeSantis New York Undercover Rig Shoulder Leather Holster to the Test

First Use Experience

My testing grounds for this holster were primarily within urban and personal environments, focusing on concealed carry scenarios. This meant putting it through its paces during daily commutes, extended periods of wear while performing routine tasks, and occasional practice draws. The holster was tested with a full-size handgun, as its design implies, and I paid close attention to its behavior under various conditions—from the warmth of a seated position to the slight constriction of wearing a jacket.

Initial wear revealed that the DeSantis New York Undercover Rig Shoulder Leather Holster offers a substantial feel. The leather, while promising, required a bit of breaking in to conform perfectly. Adjusting the harness to find the sweet spot for comfort and firearm retention took some fiddling, especially at the four pivot points. I did note that the leather, being unlined, had a tendency to feel a little rough against clothing during vigorous movement, though this was a minor point in the grand scheme of things.

Extended Use & Reliability

Over several months of consistent, albeit not daily, use, this shoulder rig has demonstrated a degree of resilience. The top-grain cowhide has softened nicely, and the molding to the specific firearm has held its shape remarkably well. The thumb break, a crucial element for security, has proven reliable, offering a positive click when engaged and a smooth, swift release when needed. I experienced no issues with the holster failing to retain the firearm, even during moderate physical exertion like bending or reaching.

Maintenance has been straightforward; a simple wipe-down with a leather conditioner every few weeks has kept the material supple and protected. I’ve noticed no significant wear on the leather itself, nor any degradation in the stitching or hardware. Compared to some synthetic holsters that can lose their shape or develop creaks, this leather rig feels more enduring, though perhaps not as lightweight or breathable as some modern alternatives. The user feedback mentioning extended wait times for delivery is a valid point that affects the overall purchase experience, but once in hand, the holster itself holds up.

Breaking Down the Features of the DeSantis New York Undercover Rig Shoulder Leather Holster

Specifications

The DeSantis New York Undercover Rig Shoulder Leather Holster is constructed from top-grain cowhide, chosen for its durability and ability to be molded precisely to the intended firearm. This specific model is designed for full-size firearms with barrel lengths ranging from 3 to 5 inches. The rig comes fully assembled and includes an integrated double ammo carrier, a valuable feature for quick reloads. The harness is adjustable to fit chests up to 54 inches, a generous range accommodating a wide variety of body types.

Crucially, the holster features a thumb break closure, offering a secure method of retention that can be disengaged with a flick of the thumb. The leather is available in plain, unlined finishes in either black or tan. The pivot points at all four junction points of the harness are designed to allow for better movement and comfort, adapting to the wearer’s posture. These specifications collectively aim to provide a secure, accessible, and comfortable carry solution for a substantial firearm.

Performance & Functionality

In terms of its primary function, retaining and presenting a firearm, this shoulder holster performs commendably. The molded leather cup holds the pistol securely, and the thumb break mechanism is both robust and accessible. Drawing the firearm is a fluid motion once the thumb break is released, with the firearm sliding smoothly from the holster.

The double ammo carrier is a practical addition, keeping spare magazines readily available without adding excessive bulk. The balance of the rig, when worn correctly, distributes the weight effectively, minimizing discomfort during prolonged wear. However, the unlined nature of the leather means that the interior can feel a bit rough against the firearm’s finish over time, and it also absorbs moisture more readily than lined holsters. This is a trade-off for the traditional aesthetic and the tactile feel of pure leather.

Design & Ergonomics

The design of the DeSantis New York Undercover Rig Shoulder Leather Holster harks back to a classic, time-tested silhouette. Its construction from top-grain cowhide lends it an immediate air of quality and durability. The molding is precise, ensuring a snug fit for the firearm it’s designed to carry.

Ergonomically, the harness is designed for broad adjustability, with four pivot points allowing it to move with the wearer. While this offers good mobility, achieving the perfect fit can take some trial and error. The unlined leather, while authentic, can sometimes feel a little stiff against skin or inner clothing layers, especially during warmer weather or strenuous activity. The overall feel is substantial and reassuring, conveying a sense of dependable security.

Durability & Maintenance

This holster is built to last, a common characteristic of well-crafted leather goods. The top-grain cowhide is inherently durable, and the robust stitching suggests longevity. For a shoulder holster designed to carry a substantial firearm, the materials and construction appear to be up to the task of long-term use.

Maintenance is relatively simple, primarily involving occasional conditioning of the leather to keep it supple and prevent drying or cracking. The metal hardware, such as buckles and the thumb break stud, is sturdy and should withstand regular use without issue. Potential points of wear might include the edges of the leather where it flexes most, but with proper care, this rig should serve for many years. It’s not a disposable item; it’s an investment in a piece of gear designed for enduring service.

Accessories and Customization Options

The DeSantis New York Undercover Rig Shoulder Leather Holster comes as a fully assembled rig, which is a significant convenience. The inclusion of a double ammo carrier as part of the standard package is a key selling point, offering immediate utility without requiring additional purchases. This integrated carrier is designed to match the holster’s material and finish, providing a cohesive look.

While the core rig is comprehensive, DeSantis does offer additional accessories separately for those who might wish to further customize their setup. However, the base package, with its integrated ammo pouch, is quite complete for its intended purpose. Unlike some modular systems, this particular model emphasizes a more classic, fixed configuration, with the primary customization coming from the adjustability of the harness and the choice between black or tan finish.

Pros and Cons of the DeSantis New York Undercover Rig Shoulder Leather Holster

Who Should Buy the DeSantis New York Undercover Rig Shoulder Leather Holster?

This shoulder holster is an excellent choice for individuals who carry full-size firearms and appreciate a classic, durable leather design. It is particularly well-suited for those who prioritize a secure retention system like a thumb break and value the convenience of an integrated ammo carrier. Anyone who needs a comfortable, adjustable rig that can accommodate a larger chest size will find the DeSantis New York Undercover Rig Shoulder Leather Holster a practical option.

However, those seeking an ultra-lightweight, highly breathable, or extremely minimalist carry solution might find this holster a bit too substantial. If you prefer lined holsters or have extremely sensitive skin that might react to unlined leather, other options might be more suitable. For optimal performance, consider a good quality leather conditioner to maintain the hide and a proper fitting session to dial in the harness adjustments.

Conclusion on the DeSantis New York Undercover Rig Shoulder Leather Holster

The DeSantis New York Undercover Rig Shoulder Leather Holster stands as a testament to enduring design, offering a robust and secure method for carrying full-size handguns. Its construction from top-grain cowhide and the precise molding for specific firearms translate into a reliable and durable piece of equipment. The integrated double ammo carrier and the broad adjustability of the harness further enhance its practicality for everyday carry.

While the unlined leather and potential for extended shipping times are points to consider, the overall value proposition remains strong, especially given its competitive price point. For those who appreciate traditional craftsmanship, secure retention, and a holster built for longevity, this model from DeSantis is a highly recommendable choice. It provides a blend of time-tested functionality and modern necessity, making it a solid contender for anyone in the market for a dependable shoulder rig.