Old Timer Middleman Knife Review

Why I Chose the Old Timer Middleman Knife: A Hands-On Review

My quest for a reliable, everyday carry knife that doesn’t break the bank led me to the Old Timer Middleman Knife. For years, I’ve juggled various tools, from precision instruments in the lab to rugged companions in the workshop, each demanding specific qualities. This particular model from Old Timer caught my eye due to its promise of versatility and a classic design, featuring a trio of blades that hinted at broad utility. My existing EDC was starting to show its age, and I needed something that could handle anything from opening mail to light whittling without fuss. Considering its price point, it seemed like a solid contender against more expensive, single-purpose blades. My initial impression upon holding it was one of understated quality; it felt solid and well-constructed, instilling a quiet sense of confidence.

Real-World Testing: Putting Old Timer Middleman Knife to the Test

First Use Experience

My initial tests for this knife focused on everyday tasks that mirror my daily routines. I used it at my workbench for opening boxes of components, cutting heat-shrink tubing, and stripping the occasional wire. It also saw duty around the house for opening mail and slicing through packaging. In the field, so to speak, I brought it along on a weekend camping trip where it proved surprisingly handy for trimming cordage and preparing some tinder. The knife performed admirably under these varied conditions, showing no immediate signs of faltering. Its intuitive design meant I didn’t need any special instruction; it felt familiar from the moment I picked it up.

The three blades on this knife offer distinct advantages for different tasks. The clip-point blade handled general cutting with ease, slicing through tape and paper cleanly. For more precise work, like scoring material or trimming small items, the sheepsfoot blade was invaluable, its flat edge providing excellent control. The smaller pen blade proved useful for tighter spaces and delicate scoring tasks. I experienced no significant issues during these initial uses, though I did notice the nail nicks required a firm, deliberate pull to engage the blades.

Extended Use & Reliability

After several months of consistent, albeit not heavy-duty, use, the Old Timer Middleman Knife has proven itself to be a steadfast companion. It lives in my pocket, accompanying me to the workshop, lab, and on casual outings. The blades have held up well, showing only minor signs of use consistent with regular sharpening. The nickel silver bolsters still gleam, and the Desert Ironwood handles have developed a pleasant patina, feeling more comfortable with each passing day.

Durability has been excellent for its class; there are no cracks in the handles, no excessive play in the blades, and the back springs retain their tension reliably. Maintenance is straightforward: a quick rinse and dry after exposure to any moisture, and a light oiling of the pivot point every few weeks. I find myself sharpening the blades about once a month, which is easily done with a simple whetstone. Compared to some of the flimsier promotional knives I’ve encountered, or even some budget multi-tools that promised more but delivered less, this Old Timer feels significantly more robust and dependable.

Breaking Down the Features of Old Timer Middleman Knife

Specifications

The Old Timer Middleman Knife is a folding pocket knife designed for everyday utility. It features a 2.4-inch clip point blade, a sheepsfoot blade, and a clip point pen blade, all designed with convenient nail pulls for easy opening. The handles are crafted from a beautiful Desert Ironwood, accented by nickel silver bolsters, brass pins, and robust, heat-treated back springs.

The overall length of the knife when open is 5.7 inches, with a closed length of 3.3 inches, making it compact enough for pocket carry. It weighs a mere 1.8 ounces, so it won’t add noticeable bulk. The blades are made from 7Cr17 High Carbon Stainless Steel, a reliable material known for its balance of edge retention and corrosion resistance. This material choice is crucial for a knife intended for regular use across various environments.

The handle material is listed as Delrin in one place and Bone in another, but the actual product features striking Desert Ironwood, which provides a warm, secure grip. This natural material, combined with the sturdy nickel silver bolsters, contributes to the knife’s classic aesthetic and solid feel. The brass pins reinforce the construction, holding the scales firmly to the frame. The heat-treated back springs are vital for the snap and security of the folding blades, ensuring they stay open when in use and closed when not.

Performance & Functionality

In practice, the Old Timer Middleman Knife excels at its intended purpose: general utility. The primary clip point blade is sharp out of the box and handles common tasks like opening packages and cutting string with ease. Its shape allows for decent penetration and slicing. The sheepsfoot blade is a welcome addition, offering a flat, safe edge perfect for controlled cutting and scraping without the risk of accidentally piercing.

The secondary clip point pen blade is smaller but still functional for fine detail work or when the larger blades are too much. All three blades deploy smoothly using the nail nicks, though they require a firm pull. The action is solid, with no significant blade play once opened. While it’s not a high-performance blade for heavy-duty tasks, for its size and price, its performance is commendable. It reliably performs its core functions, making it a versatile tool for a wide range of common needs.

Design & Ergonomics

The design of the Old Timer Middleman Knife is a testament to classic pocket knife aesthetics, yet it feels surprisingly modern in hand. The Desert Ironwood handles are beautifully finished, offering a comfortable and secure grip even when my hands are a little slick. The natural wood grain provides a unique character to each knife. The nickel silver bolsters are smoothly integrated, adding a touch of elegance and providing protection for the handle scales.

The overall shape is ergonomic, fitting well into the palm for controlled cutting. The brass pins are neatly finished, contributing to the knife’s refined appearance. One small point of ergonomic consideration is the placement of the nail pulls; they are functional but could benefit from being slightly deeper or more textured for those with less grip strength, especially when the blades are new and stiff. However, once engaged, the secure lock-up ensures the blades stay in place.

Durability & Maintenance

The Old Timer Middleman Knife feels built to last for its intended purpose. The 7Cr17 MoV High Carbon Stainless Steel blades resist corrosion remarkably well, even after being exposed to some damp conditions. The Desert Ironwood handles are durable and resist scratching better than many synthetic materials. The heat-treated back springs provide a satisfying snap and show no signs of weakening after repeated use.

Maintenance is refreshingly simple. A quick wipe-down with a dry cloth after use is usually sufficient. For deeper cleaning or after exposure to more demanding environments, a mild soap and water solution followed by thorough drying and a light application of mineral oil to the pivot and blades will keep it in top condition. There are no complex mechanisms or tricky crevices that make cleaning difficult. I anticipate this knife will remain a reliable tool for many years with minimal care.

Accessories and Customization Options

This particular model of the Old Timer Middleman Knife comes as a standalone tool. There are no specific accessories included in the package. However, the inherent design of classic pocket knives lends itself to certain complementary items. A good quality leather pouch or pocket slip can help protect the knife from keys and other items in a pocket, preserving its finish.

While Old Timer knives are generally not designed for extensive modification, the simplicity of their construction means that replacement parts like springs are sometimes available from specialty retailers, though this is rarely necessary for standard use. The core customization lies in the user’s ability to maintain and sharpen the blades to their personal preference, a key aspect of owning a quality folding knife.

Pros and Cons of Old Timer Middleman Knife

Who Should Buy Old Timer Middleman Knife?

This Old Timer Middleman Knife is an ideal choice for anyone seeking a reliable, multi-purpose folding knife for general daily use. It’s perfect for individuals working in workshops, labs, or even just the average homeowner who needs a dependable tool for various small tasks. Hobbyists, makers, and anyone who appreciates classic craftsmanship will find it a welcome addition to their toolkit.

Those who prioritize affordability without compromising on quality and functionality will be well-served by this model. However, if you require a knife for extremely demanding tasks, such as heavy prying, batonning wood, or prolonged exposure to saltwater environments, you might want to consider a knife with a more robust blade steel and a single, heavy-duty blade. Similarly, if a built-in pocket clip is a non-negotiable feature for your EDC, this knife might require a complementary carrying solution like a pouch.

Conclusion on Old Timer Middleman Knife

The Old Timer Middleman Knife stands out as a remarkably well-executed folding knife, especially considering its $31.99 price tag. It successfully marries classic design principles with practical functionality, offering a versatile set of blades housed within a durable and aesthetically pleasing package. The combination of Desert Ironwood handles, nickel silver bolsters, and reliable 7Cr17 High Carbon Stainless Steel blades makes it a joy to use and hold.

Its value proposition is exceptional; you receive a knife that performs admirably in a wide array of everyday tasks without the hefty cost often associated with premium pocket tools. While the nail nicks could be a touch easier to engage, this is a minor point in the face of its overall quality and performance. For anyone looking for a dependable, attractive, and functional everyday carry knife that won’t break the bank, I would wholeheartedly recommend the Old Timer Middleman Knife. It’s a testament to Old Timer‘s heritage and a solid choice for practical users.