Carlson’s Choke Tubes Black Cloud Benelli Crio/Crio Plus 20ga 2 Pack, MR & LR: Review

Breaking Down My First Experience with the Carlson’s Choke Tubes Black Cloud Benelli Crio/Crio Plus 20ga 2 Pack, MR & LR:

As an equipment specialist with over a decade immersed in diverse environments, from dusty workshops to sterile labs and rugged outdoor expeditions, my standards for gear are uncompromisingly high. When the need arose for precision constriction in my 20-gauge Benelli, specifically for the demanding performance characteristics associated with modern waterfowl loads like Black Cloud, my search led me to the Carlson’s Choke Tubes Black Cloud Benelli Crio/Crio Plus 20ga 2 Pack, MR & LR:. This particular set promised to deliver optimized patterns for both mid-range and long-range engagements, a crucial factor for any serious waterfowler. I was initially drawn to this pack by Carlson’s established reputation for quality aftermarket choke tubes, especially their specialized lines designed for specific ammunition types.

My previous choke tube, a generic model, simply wasn’t cutting it with the newer, faster, and denser shot payloads common in waterfowl hunting today. I was experiencing disappointing patterns at moderate distances, a problem that needed a definitive solution before the upcoming season. The prospect of a purpose-built choke system, particularly one engineered for the Benelli Crio/Crio Plus platform, offered a tangible improvement pathway. My first impression upon unboxing the Carlson’s Choke Tubes Black Cloud Benelli Crio/Crio Plus 20ga 2 Pack, MR & LR: was one of solid engineering. The weight felt substantial yet balanced, and the titanium finish exuded a professional, durable aesthetic.

Compared to some other brands that offer single choke tubes at a similar price point, this two-pack seemed to offer superior value right out of the gate. The inclusion of both a Mid-Range and Long-Range option meant immediate versatility without needing to purchase them separately. My initial reaction was a surge of focused curiosity, anticipating the tangible difference these tubes would make in the field.

Real-World Testing: Putting Carlson’s Choke Tubes Black Cloud Benelli Crio/Crio Plus 20ga 2 Pack, MR & LR: to the Test

First Use Experience

My testing primarily took place at my local clay shooting range and, more importantly, during several early morning waterfowl hunts. The conditions varied from crisp autumn mornings with light frost to damp, overcast days with a persistent mist. I specifically chose the MR (Mid-Range) tube for the initial test on a skeet course to gauge its performance with smaller shot sizes and closer targets, and then switched to the LR (Long-Range) tube for field applications with heavier waterfowl loads. The installation was straightforward; both tubes threaded smoothly into my Benelli Crio Plus receiver, a testament to their precise manufacturing.

In terms of ease of use, the threaded design is standard and intuitive for anyone familiar with shotguns. There was no significant learning curve, which was a relief. However, I did notice that the Carlson’s Choke Tubes Black Cloud Benelli Crio/Crio Plus 20ga 2 Pack, MR & LR:, particularly the LR tube, required a slightly firmer hand to seat completely compared to my old factory tube. This wasn’t an issue of cross-threading, but rather a snug fit that inspires confidence in its secure placement. My only minor surprise was how much cleaner the shotshell wads seemed to exit the barrel with these tubes; less plastic fouling on the choke itself was immediately apparent.

Extended Use & Reliability

After several weeks of consistent use across multiple hunting excursions and practice sessions, the performance of this two-pack of choke tubes has held up admirably. I’ve subjected them to repeated firing with various loads, including magnum 3-inch shells loaded with BB and #2 shot, and the patterns remain impressively consistent. There are no signs of structural wear; the 17-4 Heat Treated Stainless Steel with titanium coating shows no significant scuffs or damage, even after a couple of accidental bumps against blind structures.

Maintenance has been surprisingly simple. A quick wipe-down with a silicone cloth after each outing, and occasional brushing with a standard choke tube brush, has kept them free of residue. Unlike some ported chokes I’ve used in the past, these non-ported models don’t collect excessive carbon buildup. Compared to my old, generalized choke tube, these Carlson’s tubes offer a noticeable improvement in pattern density and uniformity, especially at the advertised ranges. Budget choke tubes I’ve tested previously often show a drop in performance after just a few outings, but these have maintained their integrity and effectiveness.

Breaking Down the Features of Carlson’s Choke Tubes Black Cloud Benelli Crio/Crio Plus 20ga 2 Pack, MR & LR:

Specifications

The Carlson’s Choke Tubes Black Cloud Benelli Crio/Crio Plus 20ga 2 Pack, MR & LR: comes equipped with specifications that clearly articulate its purpose and build quality. The core material is 17-4 Heat Treated Stainless Steel, renowned for its strength, corrosion resistance, and durability, which is further enhanced by a titanium coating. This coating not only contributes to the striking Titanium color but also adds an extra layer of protection against the elements and abrasion. The gauge is specifically 20, designed to integrate seamlessly with Benelli firearms.

These choke tubes utilize the Benelli Crio Plus choke tube system, ensuring precise fitment and function with compatible Benelli shotguns. The pack includes two distinct choke types: Mid Range (MR) and Long Range (LR). The diameters are listed as 0.605 inches for the MR and 0.595 inches for the LR, indicating controlled constriction designed for specific shooting distances. Each choke tube is non-ported, meaning they lack vents to reduce recoil or muzzle jump, focusing instead on tight pattern constriction. The pack contains 2 choke tubes and importantly, includes a choke wrench for installation and removal. These tubes are proudly made in the USA.

The 0.605-inch diameter of the MR tube is a subtle constriction, ideal for delivering dense patterns at moderate distances where quick shots are common. This specification translates to better performance with various shot sizes commonly used for upland game or closer-range waterfowl. Conversely, the 0.595-inch diameter of the LR tube offers a tighter constriction, designed to keep shot strings together for those critical long-range opportunities often encountered when pursuing ducks or geese at the edge of effective range. The choice of 17-4 Heat Treated Stainless Steel provides a robust foundation, capable of withstanding the pressures and heat generated by modern shotshells without deforming or losing its precise dimensions over time. The titanium coating is more than just cosmetic; it offers a slick surface that aids in easier cleaning and prevents buildup of lead and plastic fouling, which is a significant advantage for sustained performance in challenging field conditions.

Performance & Functionality

The primary job of the Carlson’s Choke Tubes Black Cloud Benelli Crio/Crio Plus 20ga 2 Pack, MR & LR: is to enhance shotgun patterns, and in this regard, they excel. The MR tube consistently produced tight, even patterns with 7.5 and 6 shot at ranges up to 30 yards, significantly improving perceived shot density compared to my previous choke. When using heavier loads like BB and #2 shot, the LR tube demonstrated remarkable effectiveness, keeping a high percentage of pellets within a designated kill zone at ranges I previously considered marginal. This is where the 0.595-inch diameter truly shines, maintaining shot string integrity for clean kills.

A significant strength of this set is the clear distinction in performance between the MR and LR tubes; they are not just marketing variations but distinct tools for different scenarios. The non-ported design, while not reducing recoil directly, contributes to a cleaner barrel and easier maintenance. The main weakness, if it can be called that, is that the tighter constriction of the LR tube can be detrimental at very close ranges, potentially over-patterning or cutting through targets rather than cleanly disabling them. However, this is inherent to tighter chokes and not a flaw in the product itself. For their intended use with specialized loads like Black Cloud, they not only meet but exceed expectations, offering reliable performance that translates directly to improved effectiveness in the field.

Design & Ergonomics

The design of these choke tubes is both functional and aesthetically pleasing. The titanium coating gives them a premium look, and the precision machining is evident upon closer inspection. The knurled section at the end of each tube provides a decent grip for hand-tightening, although the included choke wrench is essential for proper installation and removal. The 17-4 Heat Treated Stainless Steel construction lends a substantial feel, suggesting a product built to last.

Ergonomically, they are designed for their specific firearm platform, the Benelli Crio Plus. They seat firmly and don’t exhibit any wobble once installed correctly. The clean, non-ported design is a subtle but welcome feature, making them less prone to collecting mud or debris in tough field conditions. The clear markings indicating MR and LR are easy to read, preventing confusion in the field when making a quick change. The overall feel is one of robust, no-nonsense engineering focused on delivering optimal ballistic performance.

Durability & Maintenance

Based on my experience and the materials used, these choke tubes are built for longevity. The 17-4 Heat Treated Stainless Steel with titanium coating is highly resistant to corrosion and wear, suggesting that they will endure many seasons of rigorous use. I haven’t encountered any issues with expansion, cracking, or deformation, even after firing numerous magnum loads.

Maintenance is straightforward, primarily involving cleaning to remove shot residue and fouling. The slick surface of the titanium coating actually makes this easier than with uncoated steel chokes. I typically clean them with a standard choke tube brush and a light application of gun oil or CLP. There are no specific maintenance tips beyond standard firearm care, which is a plus for ease of ownership. I have no concerns about potential failure points in normal operation for their intended use.

Accessories and Customization Options

The Carlson’s Choke Tubes Black Cloud Benelli Crio/Crio Plus 20ga 2 Pack, MR & LR: pack is relatively self-contained. The most crucial included accessory is the choke wrench, which is indispensable for proper installation and removal. The pack itself is a form of customization in that it provides two distinct choke constrictions – MR and LR – tailored for different shooting scenarios.

These tubes are designed specifically for the Benelli Crio/Crio Plus system, meaning they are not interchangeable with other choke tube systems like Beretta Optima or Remington ProBore. This specificity ensures optimal fit and function within the Benelli platform. While there are no further customization options for the tubes themselves, their compatibility with the broad range of Black Cloud ammunition and other modern waterfowl loads is a significant functional advantage.

Pros and Cons of Carlson’s Choke Tubes Black Cloud Benelli Crio/Crio Plus 20ga 2 Pack, MR & LR:

Who Should Buy Carlson’s Choke Tubes Black Cloud Benelli Crio/Crio Plus 20ga 2 Pack, MR & LR:?

This choke tube set is an excellent choice for serious waterfowlers who shoot a 20-gauge Benelli shotgun equipped with the Crio or Crio Plus choke system. If you frequently use specialized loads like Federal Black Cloud, or if you are looking to maximize the effectiveness of your shotgun at both mid-range and longer distances, these tubes will provide a significant performance upgrade. Hunters who appreciate precise patterning and seek reliable, durable aftermarket components will find great value here.

However, individuals who own Benelli shotguns with different choke systems (e.g., standard Benelli Mobil or other brand’s proprietary systems) should look elsewhere. Shooters who primarily hunt very close-range game where an Improved Cylinder or Skeet choke is typically sufficient might not fully utilize the benefits of the MR and LR constrictions. Also, those on a very tight budget looking for the absolute cheapest option might find single, less specialized tubes more appealing, though likely at the cost of performance. For those looking to enhance their waterfowl hunting, I’d strongly recommend pairing these with a good quality shotshell holder or a small cleaning kit for quick on-the-go maintenance.

Conclusion on Carlson’s Choke Tubes Black Cloud Benelli Crio/Crio Plus 20ga 2 Pack, MR & LR:

The Carlson’s Choke Tubes Black Cloud Benelli Crio/Crio Plus 20ga 2 Pack, MR & LR: represents a significant step up in performance for Benelli 20-gauge owners who rely on modern, specialized waterfowl loads. The combination of robust 17-4 Heat Treated Stainless Steel construction with a durable titanium coating ensures these tubes are built to withstand the rigors of frequent field use. Functionally, the distinction between the MR and LR constrictions provides true versatility, allowing for optimized patterning across a wider range of engagement distances.

Considering the price, the value proposition is strong; you are getting two high-performance, specialized choke tubes designed for specific ammunition types, along with the necessary wrench. This pack effectively bridges the gap between standard chokes and the demands of today’s high-velocity shotshells. I would wholeheartedly recommend this set to any waterfowler with a compatible Benelli shotgun who is serious about improving their shot-to-shot consistency and maximizing their effectiveness in the field. If you’re looking to wring the most performance out of your 20-gauge for waterfowl, these are a worthwhile investment.