Uncovering the DoubleStar ACE AR-15 CAR Buttstock: Real Review
The DoubleStar ACE AR-15 CAR Buttstock is a direct reproduction of the classic Vietnam-era carbine stock, aiming to provide an authentic retro feel for AR-15 builds. Crafted from aluminum with a durable coating, it promises a blend of vintage aesthetics and modern manufacturing. My search for this particular stock stemmed from a desire to complete a period-correct XM177E2 clone build. The goal was to achieve that iconic look without the astronomical cost and potential condition issues of a genuine surplus part. Upon initial inspection, the overall impression was positive; the heft and form factor immediately evoked the feel of the original. However, a closer look revealed some areas where finishing could be improved. While exploring options, I considered other reproduction stocks, but the DoubleStar’s specific focus on the CAR design and reported material quality caught my attention. My initial reaction was a sense of cautious optimism, feeling that I had found a promising piece for my project.
Real-World Testing: Putting DoubleStar ACE AR-15 CAR Buttstock to the Test
First Use Experience
My initial testing took place at my workshop and the local indoor range, aiming to replicate the conditions of a retro build completion. I mounted the stock onto a standard AR-15 carbine receiver extension, and the fit was reasonably snug, though with a touch more play than anticipated. The stock adjusted between its two positions with a satisfying click, and the coating felt robust against handling. There was no immediate performance impact on the firearm, but the visual transformation was significant, immediately bringing the build closer to its intended era.
Extended Use & Reliability
After several months of periodic use and range visits, this ACE CAR buttstock has held up reasonably well, remaining a key visual component of my retro build. While it hasn’t endured harsh elements like prolonged rain or extreme dust storms, it has survived countless magazine changes and the general wear and tear of range days. The coating, a Plastisol powder coat, shows no signs of flaking or significant scuffing, maintaining its intended appearance. Cleaning is straightforward; a quick wipe-down with a cloth is usually sufficient, and no specialized maintenance has been required. Compared to some cheaper reproductions I’ve encountered in the past, this one feels substantially more solid and durable, avoiding the flimsy feel that can plague lesser alternatives.
Breaking Down the Features of DoubleStar ACE AR-15 CAR Buttstock
Specifications
The DoubleStar ACE AR-15 CAR Buttstock is constructed from Aluminum, offering a sturdy foundation for its design. It’s specifically engineered for the AR-15 platform, fitting onto a Carbine 2 Position Buffer Tube. The stock features an Adjustable length with two distinct positions, extending from 7 inches to 10 inches. This adjustability is a key benefit, allowing for a degree of customization in fit, a significant improvement over fixed-length original CAR stocks. The Black color and the durable Plastisol powder coat finish are designed to replicate the look of original vinyl acetate coatings while offering enhanced longevity. This combination of robust materials and thoughtful design features contributes to its appeal for those seeking an authentic yet reliable retro component.
Performance & Functionality
In terms of its primary function, the DoubleStar ACE AR-15 CAR Buttstock performs as expected for a collapsible carbine stock. It reliably locks into its two positions, providing a stable platform for shouldering the firearm. The movement between positions is positive, though not as silky smooth as some modern, high-end stocks. The stock’s core job is to provide length adjustment and a solid buttplate, which it does effectively. Its main strength lies in its accurate reproduction of the original CAR stock’s form factor, making it ideal for its intended purpose.
Design & Ergonomics
The design of this AR-15 stock is a direct homage to the original Vietnam-era CAR stock, and DoubleStar has done a commendable job in capturing that look. The Rugged, aluminum construction lends it a substantial feel, unlike the often lighter plastic stocks. The ergonomic interface is basic, as expected from a reproduction, focusing on function over comfort. The buttplate is simple, and while it’s not padded, it doesn’t become uncomfortable during moderate use. The two position adjustment mechanism is straightforward, controlled by a lever that is easily accessible.
Durability & Maintenance
The DoubleStar ACE AR-15 CAR Buttstock appears to be built for longevity, especially for its intended role in retro builds. The Aluminum core is inherently durable, and the Durable coating is a significant upgrade over original finishes that could be prone to cracking or wear. Under normal range use and handling, I haven’t observed any signs of premature wear or structural compromise. Maintenance is minimal; the stock can be wiped down with a damp cloth or a mild cleaner if necessary. No specific parts require periodic replacement, making it a low-maintenance addition to any AR-15.
Accessories and Customization Options
The DoubleStar ACE AR-15 CAR Buttstock comes as a complete unit, including the necessary components for attachment to a carbine buffer tube. It includes the Carbine 2 Position Buffer Tube itself, along with the internal spring and buffer, which simplifies the purchasing process for those building a rifle from scratch. This integrated approach means you don’t need to source these individual parts separately, which is a convenient feature for builders. There are no other significant customization options inherent to the stock itself, beyond its two length adjustments.
Pros and Cons of DoubleStar ACE AR-15 CAR Buttstock
Pros
- Authentic reproduction of the original Vietnam-era CAR stock design, perfect for retro builds.
- Rugged, aluminum construction offers superior durability compared to plastic alternatives.
- Adjustable length with two distinct positions (7″ and 10″) provides some fitting flexibility.
- Durable coating offers better longevity than original finishes, maintaining appearance.
- Comes with the necessary Carbine 2 Position Buffer Tube, spring, and buffer, simplifying installation.
Cons
- Some user feedback suggests a rough interior finish on the aluminum, potentially causing gouges.
- There might be too much play between the stock and the tube for some users’ preferences.
- The original design is basic, offering limited ergonomic comfort compared to modern stocks.
- Price point is higher than many basic collapsible stocks, reflecting its specialized nature.
Who Should Buy DoubleStar ACE AR-15 CAR Buttstock?
The DoubleStar ACE AR-15 CAR Buttstock is an excellent choice for builders and enthusiasts focused on creating accurate retro AR-15 clones, particularly those aiming for XM177 or similar Vietnam-era configurations. It’s ideal for anyone who prioritizes historical accuracy and the distinctive look of the original CAR stock. Those seeking a modern, highly adjustable, or lightweight stock for tactical or competition use should look elsewhere. Someone who requires absolute tight tolerances and zero wobble might find the slight play noticeable. For these users, a premium, adjustable stock from another manufacturer would be a more suitable option.
Conclusion on DoubleStar ACE AR-15 CAR Buttstock
The DoubleStar ACE AR-15 CAR Buttstock delivers on its promise of providing an authentic-looking and durable reproduction of a classic firearm component. For the enthusiast dedicated to building a period-correct AR-15, its appeal is undeniable, offering a substantial upgrade over less authentic alternatives. While it possesses a certain rugged charm, potential buyers should be aware of the noted finishing inconsistencies and the inherent play that comes with a reproduction of this design. Considering its specialized nature and the quality of its construction, the price is justifiable for those who value historical accuracy. I would recommend this stock to anyone undertaking a retro build where authenticity is a key requirement, provided they are aware of its specific characteristics and embrace its vintage nature.