How the Medford Smooth Criminal Button Lock Surprised Me
My search for a robust, yet easily concealable everyday carry (EDC) knife recently led me to the Medford Smooth Criminal Button Lock. With over a decade of experience putting gear through its paces in everything from dusty workshops to rugged field conditions, I’ve developed a keen eye for what truly performs. This particular Medford knife promised a blend of compact design and a strong locking mechanism, a combination I desperately needed for its intended role. I’d been using a different model that, while reliable, felt a bit too large for discreet pocket carry. This smooth criminal, with its appealingly compact dimensions and the intriguing “button lock” designation, seemed like a promising alternative. My initial impression upon unboxing was one of solid, no-nonsense craftsmanship; it felt like a tool built to endure. While I briefly considered a couple of other tactical pen-knife hybrids, this Medford’s specific design caught my attention. There was an immediate sense of relief that I might have found a solution that balanced form and function perfectly.
Real-World Testing: Putting Medford Smooth Criminal Button Lock to the Test
First Use Experience
My initial testing of this Medford knife took place right on my workbench and then during my daily commute. I used it for a variety of common tasks: opening packages, trimming zip ties, and even cutting through some tough paracord. The conditions were generally controlled, but I did carry it in my pocket through light rain and temperature fluctuations.
The Medford Smooth Criminal Button Lock proved surprisingly intuitive from the outset. The button lock mechanism was easy to operate with a simple press, allowing for quick and safe deployment and retraction.
My only initial quirk was the slight weight, which felt substantial for its size, but that quickly translated into a feeling of robustness. There were no major issues, just a solid first impression of a well-built tool.
Extended Use & Reliability
After several months of consistent pocket carry and regular use, this Medford knife has held up exceptionally well. It’s been my go-to for opening mail, breaking down cardboard boxes at home, and even light utility tasks around the workshop.
Durability is clearly a strong suit; there are no visible cracks, the blade action remains smooth, and the lockup is still incredibly solid. Minimal maintenance has been required, just a quick wipe down and occasional application of lubricant to the pivot.
Compared to some of the lighter, less expensive knives I’ve used in the past, this Medford knife offers significantly better longevity and a more consistent performance profile. It’s clear this tool was designed for the long haul.
Breaking Down the Features of Medford Smooth Criminal Button Lock
Specifications
The Medford Smooth Criminal Button Lock measures a 4-inch (10.16cm) closed length, making it perfectly suited for discreet pocket carry. Its 3-inch (7.62cm) tumbled finish S35VN stainless blade offers a good balance of cutting edge and manageable size for everyday tasks. The handle is constructed from black anodized aluminum, providing a lightweight yet durable grip.
Key features include an extended tang for secure handling, a lanyard hole for additional carry options, and a pocket clip for convenient access. The knife also comes with a black nylon zippered storage case for protection when not in use. The S35VN steel is known for its excellent balance of toughness, edge retention, and corrosion resistance.
These specifications combine to create a knife that is both practical and resilient. The aluminum handle keeps the overall weight down, while the S35VN blade ensures it can handle a variety of cutting duties without excessive sharpening. The extended tang and pocket clip are simple but essential features for EDC.
Performance & Functionality
The primary function of the Medford Smooth Criminal Button Lock is, of course, cutting, and it performs this admirably. The 3-inch S35VN blade with its tumbled finish slices through materials like cardboard, tape, and paracord with surprising ease. The edge retention has been impressive; I’ve only needed to touch it up once since I received it.
The standout feature is undoubtedly the button lock mechanism. It provides a secure lockup that feels very safe and reliable, with no blade play whatsoever. This mechanism also allows for quick, one-handed deployment and retraction, which is crucial for an EDC tool.
While its cutting performance is excellent, its utility is somewhat limited by its size; it’s not designed for heavy-duty prying or chopping tasks. However, for its intended purpose as a compact EDC, its performance is exceptional.
Design & Ergonomics
The design of the Medford Smooth Criminal Button Lock is straightforward and functional, leaning heavily into utility. The black anodized aluminum handle offers a good grip, though it can become a bit slick if your hands are wet or oily. Its relatively flat profile makes it comfortable to carry in a pocket.
The 4-inch closed length is a significant ergonomic advantage for discreet carry, easily disappearing into most pockets without creating a large bulge. The extended tang offers a bit of extra security when closing the blade, preventing accidental slips, though the button lock itself is quite secure.
The overall build quality feels incredibly robust; it’s clear this knife is built to take a beating and keep on functioning. The tumbled finish on the blade hides minor scratches well, adding to its practical, workhorse aesthetic.
Durability & Maintenance
Given its construction, the Medford Smooth Criminal Button Lock is built for considerable longevity. The S35VN stainless steel blade is known for its resistance to corrosion and wear, and the anodized aluminum handle is tough and resistant to scratches. I anticipate this knife will last for many years of regular use.
Maintenance is thankfully minimal. A quick clean with a damp cloth and occasional oiling of the pivot mechanism is all that’s needed to keep it in top condition. The button lock system is generally low-maintenance and less prone to collecting debris than some other locking mechanisms.
The only potential point of concern, as with any button lock, is ensuring the button mechanism remains free of fine grit that could impede its smooth operation over time. However, the design appears to be fairly well-sealed against typical pocket lint.
Accessories and Customization Options
The Medford Smooth Criminal Button Lock comes with a black nylon zippered storage case. This is a practical inclusion for protecting the knife when it’s not being carried, especially for those who prefer to store it in a drawer or bag.
Beyond the included case, customization options are somewhat limited for this specific model, which is typical for Medford knives. The lanyard hole does allow for the attachment of lanyards or other small fobs, which can alter its aesthetics or provide an additional grip point.
While there aren’t extensive aftermarket modifications readily available for this particular model, its robust design and reliable function mean it’s built to perform well right out of the box. The focus here is on inherent quality rather than extensive modifiability.
Pros and Cons of Medford Smooth Criminal Button Lock
Pros
- Secure and reliable button lock mechanism that ensures a solid lockup.
- Excellent S35VN stainless steel blade offering great edge retention and corrosion resistance.
- Compact 4-inch closed length makes it ideal for discreet everyday carry.
- Durable black anodized aluminum handle that is lightweight yet sturdy.
- Includes a protective nylon zippered storage case.
Cons
- Handle can become slightly slick with wet or oily hands.
- Blade size, while good for EDC, limits heavy-duty utility tasks.
- Price point is on the higher end for its size category.
Who Should Buy Medford Smooth Criminal Button Lock?
The Medford Smooth Criminal Button Lock is an excellent choice for individuals who prioritize a secure locking mechanism and a durable, compact knife for everyday carry. It’s particularly well-suited for professionals who need a reliable tool that can be carried discreetly in various environments, such as office workers, tradespeople, or anyone who appreciates a robust tool for light to medium cutting tasks. If you’re looking for a premium EDC knife that offers a blend of tactical functionality and pocket-friendly dimensions, this Medford knife is a strong contender.
However, those who require a larger blade for heavy-duty chopping, prying, or extremely demanding outdoor use might find this model too small. Additionally, budget-conscious buyers looking for a basic utility knife may find the price point to be a barrier. For those seeking maximum grip security in wet conditions, adding a textured grip enhancement or a paracord wrap around the handle could be beneficial, although it’s not strictly necessary.
Conclusion on Medford Smooth Criminal Button Lock
Overall, the Medford Smooth Criminal Button Lock delivers on its promise of a secure, compact, and durable everyday carry knife. The S35VN blade performs exceptionally well in terms of sharpness and edge retention, while the button lock mechanism provides peace of mind with its solid and reliable engagement. The black anodized aluminum handle offers a comfortable grip for its size and contributes to the knife’s overall ruggedness.
Considering its price of $344.50, it positions itself as a premium EDC option. The value proposition lies in its high-quality materials, robust build, and the secure locking system, which justify the investment for those who demand reliability and performance from their daily tools. I would certainly recommend this knife to anyone looking for a top-tier, compact EDC with a focus on safety and durability. If you’re in the market for a no-nonsense blade that feels built to last and deploys with confidence, the Smooth Criminal is definitely worth considering.