Montana Decoy Co. Eichler Elk Decoy Review

Going All In on the Montana Decoy Co. Eichler Elk Decoy

For years, I’ve been chasing that elusive elk bugle echoing through the timber, and I’ve learned that in this pursuit, every ounce of advantage counts. The Montana Decoy Co. Eichler Elk Decoy caught my eye as a potential game-changer, promising portability without sacrificing realism. My previous experiences with decoys often involved bulky, cumbersome setups that added significant weight and hassle to an already challenging hunt. I needed something that could genuinely fit into my pack without making me feel like I was hauling a whole elk carcass.

Upon receiving it, my initial impression was one of cautious optimism. The material felt durable yet surprisingly light. Fred Eichler’s reputation precedes him, and the idea of a decoy designed by an expert hunter who understands the demands of the field was compelling. I’d looked at other full-body options, but they often seemed overly complex or just too large to reasonably carry deep into the backcountry. This one, however, felt different. My first reaction was one of quiet satisfaction; it felt like a practical solution to a common hunter’s dilemma.

Real-World Testing: Putting Montana Decoy Co. Eichler Elk Decoy to the Test

First Use Experience

My first outing with this elk decoy was in the early crisp mornings of archery season, deep in the Montana backcountry. I tested it in a variety of terrain, from open meadows edged with aspen to denser timberline stands. The setup process, even in the pre-dawn light with numb fingers, was remarkably straightforward, which is a critical factor when every second counts.

Even with dew clinging to the grass and a light mountain breeze, the decoy held its pose, presenting a convincing profile. I was particularly impressed with how quickly it deployed; what could have been a frantic rush to set up was instead a controlled and efficient process. The only minor quirk was ensuring the stakes were firmly planted in the somewhat rocky soil, but that’s a common challenge in that environment.

Extended Use & Reliability

Over the course of several hunting trips spanning different elevations and weather conditions, the Montana Decoy Co. Eichler Elk Decoy has held up exceptionally well. I’ve packed it in and out numerous times, and despite being compressed and jostled in my backpack, it consistently springs back into shape. There are no signs of cracking, stiffness, or any degradation in the printed realism, even after being subjected to occasional rain showers and strong winds.

Maintenance is virtually non-existent, which is a huge plus. After a hunt, a quick brush to remove any loose debris is all that’s needed before folding it back up for storage. Compared to inflatable decoys I’ve used in the past, which always carry the risk of punctures, or rigid decoys that are a nightmare to transport, this fabric decoy offers a superior balance of durability and convenience.

Breaking Down the Features of Montana Decoy Co. Eichler Elk Decoy

Specifications

The Montana Decoy Co. Eichler Elk Decoy boasts a folded size of a manageable 19″ x 12″, making it exceptionally packable. When unfolded, it presents a substantial 47″ x 30″ profile, designed to mimic a mature cow elk. Crucially, it weighs in at a very reasonable 40 oz., which includes the integrated poles, strings, and clips.

This 40 oz. weight is a significant specification, as it means hunters aren’t burdened with excessive gear when making long treks. The 19″ x 12″ folded dimensions ensure it can slide into most standard hunting packs without issue. The head-on cow elk pose is a deliberate design choice, intended to draw bulls in close for a shot.

Performance & Functionality

In its primary role, the Eichler Elk decoy performs admirably. The photo-realistic print on the fabric does an excellent job of drawing the eye and creating the illusion of a live animal. I’ve observed bulls exhibiting curiosity and even some hesitant approaches when presented with this decoy.

Its main strength lies in its portability and quick setup, which directly translates to more opportunities in the field. However, it’s important to manage expectations; it’s a flat decoy, and in very still air or with wary bulls, more experienced animals might detect its two-dimensional nature. Still, for its intended purpose and price point, its performance is highly satisfactory.

Design & Ergonomics

The design prioritizes functionality and portability, which is evident in its construction. The material feels robust, and the printing is well-applied, giving it a believable appearance from a distance. The inclusion of a string-and-clip hanging system alongside stakes provides versatility for different setups.

Ergonomically, the decoy is designed for ease of use in the field. It deploys quickly, and the integrated poles provide just enough structure to hold its shape. While it’s not a 3D decoy that truly mimics natural movement, the design is smart, allowing for a convincing stationary presence.

Durability & Maintenance

Based on my usage, this Montana Decoy Co. product appears built for the demands of backcountry hunting. The fabric is resilient, and I haven’t noticed any fraying or tears despite being packed tightly and exposed to the elements. Its simplified design means fewer moving parts to fail.

Maintenance is refreshingly simple. A quick wipe-down or brushing is usually sufficient. The lack of complex mechanisms means there’s little to go wrong, contributing to its overall longevity and reliability in the field.

Accessories and Customization Options

The Montana Decoy Co. Eichler Elk Decoy comes with its essential setup hardware, including poles, strings, and clips. It also includes stakes for ground placement, which are crucial for stability. A significant bonus is the Free DVD by Fred Eichler included with the decoy, offering valuable tips for using decoys effectively.

While the decoy itself is not inherently customizable in terms of shape or material, its compatibility with the Quickstand (sold separately) is a notable option. This aftermarket accessory could potentially enhance its stability and visibility in certain scenarios.

Pros and Cons of Montana Decoy Co. Eichler Elk Decoy

Who Should Buy Montana Decoy Co. Eichler Elk Decoy?

This decoy is an ideal choice for any elk hunter who values portability and needs to cover significant ground. Archery hunters, in particular, will appreciate its ability to be carried deep into the backcountry without adding excessive bulk. It’s perfect for those who rely on patience and strategic placement rather than elaborate setups.

Hunters who prioritize ease of use and quick deployment will also find this model incredibly beneficial. Those who have struggled with heavy or bulky decoys in the past should seriously consider this option. It’s probably not the best fit for hunters who exclusively use truck-access blinds or have a dedicated rig for transporting larger gear, or those looking for a hyper-realistic 3D decoy for close-quarters situations where wind detection is paramount.

A crucial complementary item would be understanding the tactics presented in the included Free DVD by Fred Eichler; the decoy is only as effective as the hunter’s ability to use it strategically.

Conclusion on Montana Decoy Co. Eichler Elk Decoy

The Montana Decoy Co. Eichler Elk Decoy stands out as a remarkably well-executed piece of hunting gear, particularly for those who chase elk through challenging terrain. Its combination of extreme portability and effective realism at a $124.49 price point makes it a compelling option. While it’s a flat decoy and won’t replicate the full presence of a live animal, its strengths in packability, rapid deployment, and the educational bonus of Fred Eichler’s DVD make it a wise investment.

I would absolutely recommend this decoy to fellow hunters, especially those venturing into remote areas where weight and pack space are at a premium. It’s a testament to smart design that allows hunters to bring a valuable tool into the field without being overly burdened, ultimately increasing their chances of success.