Was the Safariland 170 Key Ring, Silent Key Pouch 170-9 Worth It?
The Safariland 170 Key Ring, Silent Key Pouch 170-9 is a seemingly simple piece of kit, but for anyone in law enforcement, security, or even just someone who carries a lot of keys for work, it promises a significant upgrade in convenience and stealth. Made by Safariland, a name synonymous with quality duty gear, this key pouch aims to eliminate the tell-tale jingle of keys, a potential giveaway in tactical situations or when trying to maintain a low profile. This begs the question, can such a basic item truly make a difference, and is it worth the investment?
For years, I struggled with managing a bulky, noisy set of keys while on duty. My department issued a standard key ring, which was essentially a miniature mobile chandelier, announcing my presence long before I arrived. I needed a solution that would silence the keys, keep them organized, and be easily accessible when needed.
Upon receiving the Safariland 170 Key Ring, Silent Key Pouch 170-9, I immediately noticed the sturdy SAFARI-LAMINATE construction and the simple, functional design. It felt robust and well-made, exactly what I’ve come to expect from Safariland. The hook-and-loop adjustable pouch was a promising feature.
I considered other options like the ASP Key Defender or the various nylon key carriers from Blackhawk. Ultimately, I chose the Safariland pouch because of its reputation for durability and the specific design aimed at silencing keys, something the others seemed to address as an afterthought. My first impression was cautiously optimistic, hoping this unassuming pouch would finally put an end to my noisy key problem.
Real-World Testing: Putting Safariland 170 Key Ring, Silent Key Pouch 170-9 to the Test
First Use Experience
My first test of the Safariland 170 Key Ring, Silent Key Pouch 170-9 was during a night patrol in a busy downtown area. I needed quick and quiet access to various lockboxes and entry points. The weather was typical for the Pacific Northwest in the fall: damp and drizzly.
The pouch performed admirably in silencing the keys. I could move without the usual metallic chorus, a welcome change. Retrieving keys was relatively easy after a bit of practice, although the hook and loop closure required a deliberate motion to avoid ripping it open loudly.
There were no immediate issues, although I did notice the SAFARI-LAMINATE felt a little stiff in the damp conditions, requiring slightly more effort to manipulate the pouch.
Extended Use & Reliability
After several months of daily use, the Safariland 170 Key Ring, Silent Key Pouch 170-9 has proven to be a reliable piece of gear. The pouch has held up well to the constant wear and tear of duty use. There are no signs of stitching coming undone or the hook and loop losing its grip.
The SAFARI-LAMINATE shows some minor scuffing, but nothing significant. Cleaning is easy; a quick wipe with a damp cloth is usually sufficient. Compared to my previous open key ring, the Safariland pouch has significantly reduced noise and kept my keys organized, making it a definite improvement.
Breaking Down the Features of Safariland 170 Key Ring, Silent Key Pouch 170-9
Specifications
- The Safariland 170 Key Ring, Silent Key Pouch 170-9 is constructed from durable SAFARI-LAMINATE. This material provides a robust and weather-resistant exterior.
- It features a hook-and-loop adjustable pouch. This allows for secure and silent key storage and adjustable retention.
- The pouch is available in Black with a Hi Gloss finish. This provides a professional and discreet appearance.
- The design is intended for use with a standard key ring. This ensures compatibility with existing key sets.
- The finish is also available with a Nylon-Look (sample code 170-22PBL). This offers a different aesthetic option.
These specifications are important because they dictate the pouch’s durability, ease of use, and suitability for tactical or professional applications. The SAFARI-LAMINATE construction ensures longevity. The hook-and-loop closure allows for quiet operation.
Performance & Functionality
The Safariland 170 Key Ring, Silent Key Pouch 170-9 performs its primary job of silencing keys effectively. The pouch design minimizes the jingle and clatter associated with traditional key rings.
The pouch’s adjustable retention allows users to customize the fit and security of their keys. One potential improvement would be a faster, more silent closure mechanism than the hook and loop design for quicker access. The product definitely meets expectations as a simple, durable key silencer.
Design & Ergonomics
The Safariland 170 Key Ring, Silent Key Pouch 170-9 features a straightforward and functional design. The SAFARI-LAMINATE material provides a professional and durable feel.
The pouch is relatively lightweight and doesn’t add significant bulk to a duty belt or gear. It’s easy to use, with minimal learning curve.
Durability & Maintenance
The Safariland 170 Key Ring, Silent Key Pouch 170-9 is built to last. The SAFARI-LAMINATE material is resistant to abrasion and the elements.
Maintenance is simple, typically requiring only occasional cleaning. This pouch should provide years of reliable service with minimal upkeep.
Accessories and Customization Options
The Safariland 170 Key Ring, Silent Key Pouch 170-9 doesn’t come with any specific accessories. However, it is compatible with most standard key rings.
There are no specific customization options for this product. The user can potentially modify the hook-and-loop closure.
Pros and Cons of Safariland 170 Key Ring, Silent Key Pouch 170-9
Pros
- Effectively silences keys, minimizing noise during movement.
- Durable SAFARI-LAMINATE construction for long-lasting use.
- Adjustable hook-and-loop closure for secure key retention.
- Simple and functional design with minimal learning curve.
- Lightweight and adds minimal bulk to duty belt or gear.
Cons
- Hook-and-loop closure can be noisy when opened quickly.
- SAFARI-LAMINATE can be stiff in cold or wet conditions.
Who Should Buy Safariland 170 Key Ring, Silent Key Pouch 170-9?
Pros
- Effectively silences keys, minimizing noise during movement.
- Durable SAFARI-LAMINATE construction for long-lasting use.
- Adjustable hook-and-loop closure for secure key retention.
- Simple and functional design with minimal learning curve.
- Lightweight and adds minimal bulk to duty belt or gear.
Cons
- Hook-and-loop closure can be noisy when opened quickly.
- SAFARI-LAMINATE can be stiff in cold or wet conditions.
The Safariland 170 Key Ring, Silent Key Pouch 170-9 is perfect for law enforcement officers, security personnel, or anyone who needs to carry multiple keys discreetly. It’s also a great option for those who work in environments where noise discipline is important.
This product might not be ideal for individuals who only carry a few keys or prioritize extremely quick access over complete silence. A simple key clip or carabiner might be sufficient in those cases. A small bottle of hook and loop cleaner might be useful to maintain optimal closure performance over time.
Conclusion on Safariland 170 Key Ring, Silent Key Pouch 170-9
The Safariland 170 Key Ring, Silent Key Pouch 170-9 is a simple yet effective solution for silencing noisy keys. While the hook-and-loop closure isn’t perfectly silent, it significantly reduces the jingle compared to traditional key rings. The SAFARI-LAMINATE construction ensures durability and longevity.
At $39.99, the price is reasonable for the quality and functionality offered. I would definitely recommend this product to anyone looking for a reliable and discreet way to carry their keys. If you’re tired of announcing your arrival with a symphony of jangling metal, give the Safariland 170 Key Ring, Silent Key Pouch 170-9 a try. It might be the silent upgrade you didn’t know you needed.