The Good, the Bad & the Real of the Safariland COMP I Speedloader – Ambidextrous J-S5
The Safariland COMP I Speedloader – Ambidextrous J-S5 promises to be a game-changer for revolver enthusiasts seeking faster, more efficient reloads. Designed by Safariland, a name synonymous with quality duty gear, this speedloader aims to provide maximum concealment and ambidextrous functionality, particularly for smaller-framed revolvers. Is it the perfect solution for rapid reloads in the field, or does it fall short of its promises?
My interest in the Safariland COMP I arose from a very specific need: quicker reloads for my Smith & Wesson 329PD while hiking and backpacking in bear country. The thought of fumbling with individual cartridges in a high-stress situation was simply unacceptable; I needed a reliable and speedy way to get back in the fight, if necessary. I had been single-loading, and wanted a better, faster solution.
Upon receiving the COMP I, my initial impression was positive, yet somewhat reserved. The injection-molded plastic felt sturdy enough, but significantly lighter than the aluminum speedloaders I’ve used in the past. Its small knob design seemed genuinely geared towards concealment, but I wondered if it would compromise the speed and ease of use.
I was debating between this Safariland model and two similar products: the HKS Speedloader and the 5 Star Firearms J-Frame Speedloader. The HKS is a classic, known for its simplicity, but I wanted something potentially more concealable. The 5 Star model is beautifully machined, but the price point was significantly higher, and concealment wasn’t as paramount in its design.
My first impression was a mix of cautious optimism and curiosity. I was excited to see if the COMP I’s emphasis on concealment translated into a practical advantage in the field. But I also worried that its smaller size might make it more difficult to manipulate under pressure.
Real-World Testing: Putting Safariland COMP I Speedloader – Ambidextrous J-S5 to the Test
First Use Experience
My first real test of the Safariland COMP I Speedloader was at my local shooting range. I focused on drawing the speedloader from my pocket, aligning it with the cylinder of my 329PD, and releasing the cartridges. The dry, controlled environment of the range allowed me to focus solely on the mechanics of the reload.
The performance was surprisingly smooth, even with my large hands. The smaller knob, while initially a concern, proved to be adequate for a secure grip and positive release. I initially thought I would have a tough time with it, but was pleasantly surprised. The COMP I functioned reliably, even with the cylinder coated in carbon and lubricant.
The initial learning curve was minimal; after a few practice runs, I was able to achieve significantly faster reloads than with my previous method of single-loading rounds. There were no major issues, although I noticed that precise alignment was crucial for a smooth and complete cartridge release.
Extended Use & Reliability
After several weeks of consistent use, both at the range and during hiking trips, the Safariland COMP I Speedloader continues to perform reliably. There are no signs of significant wear and tear on the injection-molded plastic, despite being subjected to temperature fluctuations and the general wear and tear of being carried in my pocket. It remains a crucial piece of my tactical gear.
Maintenance is incredibly simple: a quick wipe-down with a damp cloth is usually sufficient to remove any dirt or debris. I’ve found that occasional lubrication with a dry silicone spray keeps the release mechanism operating smoothly. The reliability has been stellar.
Compared to my previous experiences with bulkier aluminum speedloaders, the COMP I offers a clear advantage in terms of concealability and ease of carry. While the aluminum models might offer a slightly more robust feel, the Safariland‘s lightweight design and low profile make it a more practical choice for everyday carry. It exceeded my expectations in this area.
Breaking Down the Features of Safariland COMP I Speedloader – Ambidextrous J-S5
Specifications
The Safariland COMP I Speedloader – Ambidextrous J-S5 is specifically designed for J-frame revolvers such as the Smith & Wesson 36, 37, 38, 42, 442, 637, and 642. Its ambidextrous design makes it suitable for both right- and left-handed shooters, a crucial feature for versatility. The Safariland COMP I Speedloader – Ambidextrous J-S5 is available only in black.
The speedloader is constructed from injection-molded plastic, providing a balance of durability and lightweight design. The smooth finish ensures easy handling and reduces friction during deployment. The attachment type is a simple slide, allowing for quick and secure cartridge release.
The steel internal components provide support for the structure. The small knob is geared toward maximum concealment. These specifications translate to a speedloader that is both functional and discreet, ideal for concealed carry or situations where minimizing profile is essential.
Performance & Functionality
The Safariland COMP I excels at its primary task: facilitating rapid reloads for J-frame revolvers. The cartridges are held securely in place until released by a simple push of the knob. This allows for a quick and efficient transfer of all five rounds into the cylinder simultaneously.
The main strength of the COMP I is its compact size and ease of concealment. The small knob design minimizes bulk, making it less likely to print through clothing. The primary weakness is that the small knob can be difficult for some users.
The Safariland COMP I Speedloader – Ambidextrous J-S5 does meet my expectations. Its ease of use and concealment capabilities are exactly what I was looking for in a speedloader for my 329PD. I was very impressed by it’s ability to do it’s job while maintaining a very minimal profile.
Design & Ergonomics
The build quality of the Safariland COMP I Speedloader is good, given its injection-molded plastic construction. The materials feel durable enough for regular use, and the lightweight design makes it comfortable to carry. The smooth finish minimizes friction and allows for easy manipulation.
The Safariland COMP I Speedloader – Ambidextrous J-S5 is user-friendly and intuitive, even for those new to speedloaders. The simple push-button release mechanism requires minimal practice to master. The ambidextrous design further enhances usability for a wider range of shooters.
Durability & Maintenance
The injection-molded plastic construction of the Safariland COMP I Speedloader is likely to withstand years of regular use. While not as robust as aluminum alternatives, it offers a good balance of durability and lightweight design. With proper care and maintenance, this speedloader should last for many years.
Maintenance is straightforward: a quick wipe-down with a damp cloth is usually sufficient to remove any dirt or grime. Occasional lubrication with a dry silicone spray can help keep the release mechanism operating smoothly. No other real maintenance is required.
Accessories and Customization Options
The Safariland COMP I Speedloader – Ambidextrous J-S5 itself doesn’t come with any specific accessories. However, it is compatible with a wide range of aftermarket accessories designed for J-frame revolvers, such as speedloader pouches and carriers. These accessories can further enhance the convenience and efficiency of carrying and deploying the speedloader.
There are no real customization options available. The design is very minimal and sleek. However, there are aftermarket pouches and carriers that will work with the speedloader.
Pros and Cons of Safariland COMP I Speedloader – Ambidextrous J-S5
Pros
- Excellent concealment due to its small knob and low profile.
- Ambidextrous design, suitable for both right- and left-handed shooters.
- Simple and reliable push-button release mechanism.
- Lightweight and durable injection-molded plastic construction.
- Affordable price point compared to metal speedloaders.
Cons
- The small knob can be difficult to use with gloved hands or by those with limited hand strength.
- Injection-molded plastic construction might not be as durable as metal alternatives.
Who Should Buy Safariland COMP I Speedloader – Ambidextrous J-S5?
The Safariland COMP I Speedloader – Ambidextrous J-S5 is perfect for concealed carriers, plainclothes law enforcement officers, or anyone who prioritizes discreetness and convenience. It is an excellent choice for those who carry J-frame revolvers as a backup weapon or for personal defense. It really is a great product for anyone looking to step up their reload game.
This product might not be ideal for competitive shooters who demand the absolute fastest reload times or for those who frequently use gloves while shooting. It may also not be ideal for users with very large hands. For these users, a larger speedloader might be a better option.
A must-have accessory is a quality speedloader pouch that allows for secure and discreet carry. Consider a leather or nylon pouch that fits snugly on your belt or in your pocket.
Conclusion on Safariland COMP I Speedloader – Ambidextrous J-S5
The Safariland COMP I Speedloader – Ambidextrous J-S5 is a well-designed and functional accessory that offers a significant advantage for J-frame revolver owners. Its emphasis on concealment, ambidextrous design, and ease of use make it a practical choice for everyday carry and personal defense. It allows for peace of mind.
At a price of $21.99, the Safariland COMP I offers excellent value for the money. The improved reload times are well worth the expense.
I would definitely recommend the Safariland COMP I Speedloader – Ambidextrous J-S5 to anyone looking for a discreet and reliable way to reload their J-frame revolver. If you value concealment and ease of use, this speedloader is an excellent investment. Upgrade your reload game today!