Safariland Open Top Als Level I Holster For S&w Review

Is the Safariland Open Top Als Level I Holster For S&w All Talk?

When you’re carrying a firearm, especially one as capable as a Smith & Wesson M&P, the holster isn’t just an accessory; it’s a critical piece of equipment. I was in a bind after a long-standing duty holster finally gave up the ghost after years of faithful service. The need for a secure, reliable replacement that wouldn’t compromise accessibility was paramount. My search led me to the Safariland Open Top Als Level I Holster For S&w, a name synonymous with quality in protective gear.

This particular model is designed for the S&W M&P Shield .45 ACP Compact (w/o Thumb Safety) and promises a Level I retention system, meaning a single point of retention. This level of security is a sweet spot for many users who need a balance between retention and a swift draw. My initial impression upon unboxing was one of robust construction; the polymer felt substantial, and the mounting hardware seemed well-engineered, a welcome sight after experiencing some flimsy alternatives in the past.

I’d briefly considered other brands, leaning towards those that offered a similar ALS (Automatic Locking System) but found myself drawn back to Safariland’s reputation for durability and field-tested designs. There was an immediate sense of relief, not just from having a replacement, but from the tangible quality that suggested this holster would be a dependable companion.

Real-World Testing: Putting Safariland Open Top Als Level I Holster For S&w to the Test

First Use Experience

My initial testing of this holster took place on a familiar indoor shooting range and then transitioned to more varied conditions during a weekend field exercise involving navigation and simulated emergency scenarios. On the range, the draw was surprisingly smooth, even with the ALS engaged; a simple press of the thumb allowed for a fluid release. The pistol sat snugly within the holster, with no discernible rattle or unnecessary movement, even when I moved rapidly between firing positions.

In the field, the holster faced more rigorous challenges. I subjected it to dusty trails, a light drizzle, and the inevitable bumps and scrapes that come with moving through rough terrain. Despite the grime and moisture, the ALS system continued to function flawlessly, and the pistol remained securely seated. There was a slight learning curve with the ALS guard, a small addition to prevent accidental disengagement of the thumb lever, but it quickly became second nature.

The holster’s design meant it integrated well with my existing tactical belt, and its profile wasn’t excessively bulky, which was a pleasant surprise given its robust build. There were no issues with the weapon becoming loose or falling out during strenuous activity, a critical factor when operating in unpredictable environments.

Extended Use & Reliability

After several weeks of consistent use, both on and off the range, the Safariland Open Top Als Level I Holster For S&w has proven its mettle. It’s become my go-to for training days and my primary choice for carrying my M&P. The polymer shows only minor cosmetic scuffs, testament to its durable construction, and more importantly, the functional components, particularly the ALS mechanism, show no signs of degradation.

Maintenance has been minimal; a quick wipe-down with a damp cloth after dusty outings is all that’s typically required. I haven’t experienced any stiffness in the locking mechanism or any loss of retention. Compared to some of the budget holsters I’ve used in the past, which would start to loosen or develop play after a few months, this Safariland model feels as solid as day one. The fit for the S&W M&P remains precise, ensuring the firearm is always presented correctly.

Breaking Down the Features of Safariland Open Top Als Level I Holster For S&w

Specifications

This open-top Level I retention holster is specifically molded for the S&W M&P Shield .45 ACP Compact (w/o Thumb Safety). It’s constructed from Safariland’s proprietary STX material, a durable polymer known for its resistance to abrasion and environmental factors. The design incorporates the ALS (Automatic Locking System), which provides passive retention until the thumb lever is actuated for a draw.

The added ALS Guard offers an extra layer of protection against accidental release of the retention lever, crucial for security in dynamic situations. This model comes in a right-hand draw configuration and features a plain black finish, a common and discreet choice for many applications. The holster attaches to the belt via Safariland’s Sentry clip, designed for secure attachment to belts up to 1.75 inches wide, ensuring it stays put during vigorous activity.

Performance & Functionality

The primary function of this holster is to securely retain a firearm while allowing for a rapid and intuitive draw. The ALS system excels at this, providing excellent retention without being overly cumbersome. The open-top design facilitates a faster acquisition of the pistol grip compared to holsters with full top flaps.

Its main strength lies in its reliable retention and smooth draw. The pistol feels locked in place until intentionally released. A minor weakness, though not significant, is that the ALS guard, while a good safety feature, can sometimes feel like an extra step for users accustomed to simpler ALS designs without it. However, for its intended purpose, it performs exceptionally well.

The holster meets and often exceeds expectations for a Level I retention holster, offering a robust solution for duty, training, and even concealed carry for those who prioritize retention. Its performance in various conditions, from dry range days to humid field excursions, has been consistently excellent.

Design & Ergonomics

The build quality of this Safariland holster is immediately apparent. The Safariland STX material feels robust and has a matte finish that minimizes glare. The molding is precise, ensuring a snug fit for the intended firearm, which is critical for both retention and preventing unnecessary wear on the weapon.

Ergonomically, the holster is designed for practical use. The angle of the draw is natural, and the ALS thumb lever is well-positioned for an immediate disengagement during a draw stroke. The Sentry clip is also a practical design element, offering a secure attachment without requiring the removal of your belt, which is a significant convenience for quick donning and doffing.

While generally comfortable, the slight protrusion of the ALS guard might take a bit of getting used to for some users, particularly if their draw stroke isn’t perfectly honed. However, this is a small price to pay for the added security it provides.

Durability & Maintenance

Based on my experience and Safariland’s reputation, this holster is built for longevity. The STX polymer is known to resist cracking and degradation from UV exposure and general wear and tear. I anticipate this holster will last for many years of hard use, far outperforming many injection-molded plastic or leather alternatives in similar price brackets.

Maintenance is straightforward. A mild soap and water solution is sufficient for cleaning, and occasional lubrication of the ALS mechanism with a silicone-based lubricant can ensure continued smooth operation. The Sentry clip is also designed for durability and is unlikely to fail under normal stress. I foresee no significant failure points with this holster under typical operational conditions for its intended use.

Accessories and Customization Options

The Safariland Open Top Als Level I Holster For S&w comes with the integrated Sentry belt clip, which is a versatile attachment system. While this specific model is a dedicated holster for the S&W M&P Shield .45 ACP Compact (w/o Thumb Safety), Safariland offers a wide range of compatible mounting platforms. These include Drop-Leg configurations, tactical vest mounts, and other belt attachment options that can be purchased separately.

This modularity is a significant advantage, allowing users to adapt the holster to different gear setups without having to buy an entirely new holster. The ALS system itself is also a core Safariland feature, compatible across many of their holster lines, which speaks to their commitment to a standardized, reliable retention mechanism.

Pros and Cons of Safariland Open Top Als Level I Holster For S&w

Who Should Buy Safariland Open Top Als Level I Holster For S&w?

This holster is an excellent choice for law enforcement officers, security professionals, competitive shooters, and responsible civilians who carry a S&W M&P Shield .45 ACP Compact (w/o Thumb Safety) and prioritize secure retention without sacrificing draw speed. It’s ideal for individuals operating in environments where the firearm’s security is paramount, such as high-risk duty assignments or rigorous training courses. Those who appreciate a solid, reliable piece of equipment that can endure demanding use will find this holster a valuable investment.

Individuals who might want to skip this are those looking for a universal fit holster or those who prefer a Level II or III retention system for maximum security. Users who opt for a concealed carry holster with a much lower profile might also find this a bit more than they need, though its design is still relatively streamlined. A good duty belt or a sturdy tactical belt is a must-have accessory to properly support the holster and firearm.

Conclusion on Safariland Open Top Als Level I Holster For S&w

The Safariland Open Top Als Level I Holster For S&w lives up to the Safariland name, offering a blend of robust security and functional design that makes it a standout choice. The ALS retention system, combined with the durable STX polymer construction and the added ALS Guard, provides confidence in the firearm’s security during intense activity. Its performance in real-world conditions has been stellar, proving its reliability for professionals and dedicated hobbyists alike.

At $157.99, the price reflects the quality and engineering that go into this holster, making it a worthwhile investment for anyone who demands reliable firearm retention. I would wholeheartedly recommend this holster to anyone carrying a compatible S&W M&P Shield .45 ACP Compact, especially those who need a dependable Level I retention solution. It’s a piece of gear that you can trust to perform when it matters most.