Safariland Open Top ALS Level I Holster Review

The Safariland Open Top ALS Level I Holster: First Use to Final Thoughts

In the world of tactical gear, reliability and rapid access are paramount, and the Safariland Open Top ALS Level I Holster aims to deliver just that. This specific model is designed for the Smith & Wesson M&P .45 (no thumb safety) with a 4.5″ barrel, presented here in a Flat Dark Earth STX Tactical finish for a right-handed user. It occupies a niche where quick draw capabilities meet dependable retention without unnecessary complexity.

My journey to this particular holster began with a need for a more secure, yet accessible, carry solution for my duty-issued M&P .45. While my previous holster offered adequate retention, the draw stroke felt cumbersome under pressure, and I was constantly looking for ways to shave precious seconds. This search led me to explore retention systems that offered a balance of security and speed, and Safariland’s ALS system consistently came up in discussions.

Upon receiving the Safariland Open Top ALS, the initial impression was one of robust construction. The STX Tactical material felt solid and well-formed, with no discernible rough edges or loose components. It exuded a no-nonsense professionalism, clearly built for serious use rather than casual carry.

During my search, I briefly considered a few other ALS-style holsters from competing brands, as well as more traditional thumb-break designs. However, the reputation of Safariland’s retention mechanisms and the specific “open-top” design of this model ultimately tipped the scales in its favor. The first reaction was one of quiet confidence; this felt like a tool that was designed with practical application firmly in mind.

Real-World Testing: Putting Safariland Open Top ALS Level I Holster to the Test

First Use Experience

My initial testing took place on the range during several intensive training sessions and at a local tactical competition. The environment was controlled but demanding, involving dynamic movement, drawing from various positions, and reholstering under simulated stress. I subjected the holster to repeated draws and reholstering cycles, ensuring the ALS mechanism engaged and disengaged smoothly with each action.

The holster performed admirably in these conditions, even when subjected to moderate dust from the outdoor range and a light sprinkle of rain during one session. The ALS retention, a key feature, engaged reliably every time the firearm was seated, providing a secure lock that I could feel and hear. Its open-top design facilitated a remarkably quick and consistent draw; once the ALS lever was depressed, the pistol slid out with minimal friction.

Getting accustomed to the ALS lever took minimal effort. The natural motion of my thumb while drawing aligned perfectly with the lever, making it an intuitive action after only a few repetitions. The only minor surprise was how securely the M&P .45 sat within the holster; it felt perfectly molded, with no unnecessary wiggle room.

Extended Use & Reliability

After several months of consistent use, both on the range and during off-duty carry, the Safariland Open Top ALS Level I Holster has proven itself to be a remarkably durable and reliable piece of equipment. It has become my go-to holster for my Smith & Wesson M&P .45.

There are no significant signs of wear and tear to report. The STX Tactical finish remains intact, showing only minor scuffs that are typical of any holster that sees regular use. The ALS mechanism continues to function with the same smooth, positive engagement and disengagement as it did on day one.

Maintenance is straightforward; a quick wipe-down with a damp cloth and occasional light application of a silicone-based lubricant to the ALS mechanism are all that’s needed. I have not experienced any issues with stiffness or performance degradation, even after exposure to sweat and varying temperatures. Compared to some budget holsters I’ve used in the past, which often develop play or stiffness over time, this Safariland unit is in a different league of longevity.

Breaking Down the Features of Safariland Open Top ALS Level I Holster

Specifications

The Safariland Open Top ALS Level I Holster is a belt holster designed with a focus on practical retention and accessibility. Its primary feature is the ALS (Automatic Locking System), which provides Level I retention. This system automatically locks the firearm in place when holstered and requires a specific thumb-activated release to draw.

The holster is constructed from STX Tactical material, a proprietary blend known for its durability and resistance to the elements. This specific model is fitted for a Smith & Wesson M&P .45 (no Thumb Safety) with a 4.5″ barrel, ensuring a precise fit. It comes in a Flat Dark Earth (FDE) color, offering a subdued tactical aesthetic, and is configured for Right Handed use.

The open-top design means there are no additional flaps or covers, allowing for a swift draw. The drop-leg configuration positions the holster lower on the thigh, which can improve accessibility when wearing body armor or load-bearing equipment. The included Safariland UFA (Universal Flex Adapter) allows for adjustment and can be attached to various belt loop systems.

Performance & Functionality

In its primary role, the Safariland Open Top ALS Level I Holster performs exceptionally well. The ALS system is the standout feature, providing a secure lock that prevents accidental disengagement while allowing for a surprisingly fast draw once the release is actuated. The fit for the M&P .45 is precise, minimizing any unnecessary movement of the firearm within the holster.

Its greatest strength is this balance between security and speed. The Level I retention is more than adequate for most tactical applications, offering peace of mind without hindering the draw. The open-top design contributes significantly to this swift access, making it ideal for situations where every second counts.

Compared to passive retention holsters or those with simpler retention mechanisms, this unit exceeds expectations for tactical scenarios. It doesn’t just meet expectations; it elevates the standard for accessible, secure handgun carry. The only minor consideration is that while it’s open-top, it doesn’t offer the absolute fastest draw of a Level II or Level III system with additional active retention, but that’s a trade-off for its simplicity and lighter weight.

Design & Ergonomics

The Safariland Open Top ALS Level I Holster showcases a practical and robust design. The STX Tactical material feels substantial and well-finished, resisting scratches and scuffs admirably during my testing period. Its construction suggests it can withstand harsh environments and heavy use without complaint.

Ergonomically, the holster is designed with efficient draw mechanics in mind. The ALS lever is positioned perfectly for a natural thumb sweep during the draw stroke. While it is a drop-leg holster, which can sometimes feel cumbersome, the included Universal Flex Adapter (UFA) and adjustable leg strap ensure a stable and comfortable fit once adjusted properly.

Key design elements include the molded contour that precisely fits the S&W M&P .45, ensuring a snug fit without excessive friction. The smooth internal lining further aids in a clean draw. There are no extraneous features to snag on gear, maintaining a streamlined profile suitable for tactical operations.

Durability & Maintenance

Based on my experience, this Safariland holster is built for the long haul. Under consistent, rigorous use, the STX Tactical construction shows no signs of fatigue. I anticipate it will continue to function reliably for years, far outlasting many alternatives.

Maintenance is minimal, which is a significant advantage for gear that is expected to perform under pressure. Beyond occasional cleaning with water and mild soap to remove dirt and sweat, there’s little to do. The ALS mechanism operates smoothly and does not appear to require any special lubrication or adjustment, although a light application of silicone spray can be beneficial for maintaining optimal glide.

The potential points of failure are minimal with this design. The ALS mechanism is a well-engineered system, and the robust material used for the holster body is unlikely to crack or deform under normal stress. It’s a workhorse that’s built to endure.

Accessories and Customization Options

This particular holster comes as a complete package ready for attachment to a belt system. The key accessory is the Safariland UFA (Universal Flex Adapter), which allows for versatile mounting onto various belt widths and configurations, including plate-style systems. It also includes an adjustable leg strap to keep the holster secure and prevent it from riding up during movement.

While the holster itself is not designed for extensive aftermarket customization in terms of its retention mechanism or material, its mounting system offers a degree of adaptability. The UFA can be removed or replaced if a different mounting solution is preferred, such as a specific belt loop or MOLLE attachment. The Flat Dark Earth finish is a cosmetic choice that suits tactical applications, and it’s unlikely to be altered.

The primary “accessory” in this context is the precise fit for the S&W M&P .45, which is crucial for optimal performance. Unlike some generic holsters, this unit is purpose-built, ensuring that the firearm sits correctly and the ALS system functions as intended.

Pros and Cons of Safariland Open Top ALS Level I Holster

Who Should Buy Safariland Open Top ALS Level I Holster?

This holster is an excellent choice for law enforcement officers, military personnel, and serious civilian tactical shooters who carry a Smith & Wesson M&P .45 (no thumb safety). It’s ideal for individuals who prioritize a fast, reliable draw combined with secure retention, especially when operating in dynamic environments or wearing body armor. The drop-leg configuration makes it particularly useful for those who need to maintain easy access to their firearm without interference from vests or gear.

Those who prefer a minimalist carry setup, lighter concealed carry options, or holsters with multiple active retention devices might want to look elsewhere. If you are primarily looking for an everyday concealed carry holster or a simple range holster without the need for a drop-leg mount, this particular model might be overkill or not fit your primary use case.

For optimal use, ensuring your belt system is compatible with the UFA is key. Pairing it with a sturdy tactical belt and potentially adding a thigh strap or stabilizing brace can further enhance its stability and comfort during rigorous activity.

Conclusion on Safariland Open Top ALS Level I Holster

The Safariland Open Top ALS Level I Holster is a testament to effective design and robust engineering. It masterfully blends speed of access with dependable retention, making it a standout choice for those who demand performance under pressure. The STX Tactical material and the precision fit for the S&W M&P .45 speak to its quality and durability, promising a long service life.

The value proposition here is clear: you are investing in a professional-grade piece of equipment that significantly enhances firearm accessibility without compromising security. While its price point is higher than many alternatives, the performance, durability, and reliability it offers justify the investment for its intended user.

I would wholeheartedly recommend this holster to anyone seeking a top-tier carry solution for their compatible Smith & Wesson M&P .45. If your operational needs demand a fast, secure draw from a drop-leg platform, the Safariland Open Top ALS Level I Holster is an outstanding option that is unlikely to disappoint. It’s a tool designed to perform when it matters most.